Category talk:Music genre articles by quality

Projects for grading the quality of articles strike me as a good idea, so I like your music genre article project. However, I think you need to take into account of the fact that some articles cover larger genres or more general categories than others. Specifically, I'm thinking of your grading Illbient as "Start-Class" articles. Keep in mind that "Illbient" and other microgenres are pretty narrow musical pigeonholes that only describe the work of a very few artists, and the genre names themselves may only be in limited use. That would imply that an extensive article on that genre simply isn't called for - the article may be short, but the subject isn't appropriate for an extensive discussion. Peter G Werner 23:38, 27 April 2006 (UTC)


 * yup, that's something that's been mentioned, but illbient only has a brief description of it's sound, no history of the term or style, no references, no images, only one link and no samples, so i'd definitly say it has room for improvement. --MilkMiruku 00:26, 28 April 2006 (UTC)