Draft talk:Claudia Reh

Missing sources?
added 13 References. Enough sources now? --Schwijker (talk) 19:23, 17 March 2023 (UTC)


 * Hello, I've left this info on your talk as well, but am posting here as well in the event that other editors may see it. Reliable sources are things like secondary sources such as newspaper articles (not press releases, but articles or reviews with a byline and content not based on a press release); magazine articles or reviews (for example in ARTFORUM magazine, Frieze, etc.) or articles in academic journals that are fully vetted and peer-reviewed; chapters in books from notable publishers. Unfortunately none of the citations you added in good faith to the article are considered reliable sources per Wikipedia's guidelines and policies. What are needed are secondary sources that are in-depth, significant coverage in reliable published sources that are fully independent of the person. Below is an analysis of why the current sourcing does not meet WP guidelines:
 * Not independent: Calendar listing for an event
 * Not a reliable source: Blog
 * Not independent: Press release, not an independent article or review about her or her work
 * Not independent: Calendar listing
 * Not independent: Festival route map
 * Not independent: Festival route map
 * Not independent: Press release
 * Not independent: Festival bio paragraph
 * Not independent: Festival participant page
 * Not independent: User-submitted material, artist’s self-published video
 * Not independent: User-submitted material, artist’s self-published video
 * Unreliable source: YouTube is not considered a reliable source and it’s a user-submitted entry
 * Unreliable source: User submitted content:
 * Flicker with pictures on it is not a reference
 * Not independent: User submitted content bio
 * Here are some links that may be helpful to you as you search for independent significant coverage in reliable sources: WP:N, WP:RS, WP:SIGCOV. What is of critical importance are sources (references) that are high quality, the number of sources is not as important - quality, not quantity is key. Hope that helps! Netherzone (talk) 23:50, 17 March 2023 (UTC)