File talk:KielerWoche1A1.png

There is a problem with the inclusion of this file in Thistle (yacht) and Meteor (Yacht). The Meteor in the picture sports no clipper bow, hence it cannot be Meteor I. There is also no record of Meteor I or Meteor II having been rerigged as a schooner. The stamp says it is Meteor, and as such it could be any of the A-Class schooners Meteor III (Archibald Cary Smith, 1902), Meteor IV (Max Oertz, 1908) or Meteor V (Max Oertz, 1914) instead of Meteor I, which further suggests that the supplied date (1890) is also wrong. Please revalidate the date to advise. Nuttyrave (talk) 10:45, 14 December 2008 (UTC)
 * It does not seem to be Meteor III, which had a straight bow, almost clipper bow, instead of the distrinctive spoon bow in the picture. Neither can it be have been Meteor V which was sailed just once before WWI and only had black hull paints. Meteor IV (Max Oertz, 1908) was white and had a similar bow as in the picture, and if the figures in 1890 and 1908 were inverted, she may be the best candidate. Nuttyrave (talk) 09:03, 7 April 2010 (UTC)