Gregory Sutton

Gregory Joseph Sutton (born 19 March 1951) is a convicted paedophile and former member of the Roman Catholic religious order of the Marist Brothers. Sutton taught in Marist Brother schools in Queensland, New South Wales and Canberra between 1973 and 1987 and served more than 12 years in prison for 67 offences against children.

The failure of the Marist Brothers to deal with Sutton's prolific offending was examined in Case Study 13 of the Royal Commission into Institutional Responses to Child Sexual Abuse.

Career
Gregory Joseph Sutton was born 19 March 1951 and grew up in the Wyong area of New South Wales. Sutton was 16 years old when he joined the Marist Brothers Juniorate. He entered the Noviate, taking his final vows in 1970. During 1971–1972, he did his Scholasticate at the Marist Brothers Champagnat College, Pagewood, New South Wales.

Sutton's younger brother Robert followed him into the Marist Brothers and later became headmaster of Marist Brothers, Hamilton school.

Marist Brothers Primary School, Queensland (1973–1976)
Sutton's first teaching appointment was Marist Brothers Primary School, Queensland in 1973. Sutton has not been convicted of any offences relating to this period but the Marist Brothers made payments to 2 former students who were sexually abused by Sutton. Brother Denis Doherty, who was in charge of primary school students, told the Royal Commission that he became uneasy about interactions between Sutton and various students.

Sutton asked Doherty for permission to take children to a holiday house at Mission Beach, Queensland. Doherty refused because he was worried for the children's safety. Doherty laid out his concerns to the Provincial Brother Charles Howard, telling him he suspected Sutton was 'interfering with children.' Later Howard wrote to Doherty to reassure him they would deal with Sutton. Doherty assumed this meant he would be counselled and closely observed.

Sacred Heart Primary School, Mosman, Sydney (1976–1978)
In 1976 Sutton was transferred to Sacred Heart Primary School, Mosman, New South Wales. In 1996 Sutton was convicted of 12 child sex offences against four boys at the school.

Marist Brothers Primary School, Eastwood, Sydney (1978–1980)
In January 1978, Sutton was transferred to Marist Brothers Primary School, Eastwood, Sydney. In 1996, he was convicted of 10 offences against four children at the school. The Community Superior Brother John Callaghan is on record as saying Sutton appeared more immature than his colleagues, citing a model train set Sutton had installed in his classroom

Marist College Junior School, Canberra (1980–1983)
In January 1980, Sutton was transferred to Marist College Junior School, Canberra and taught there until the end of the 1982 school year. Sutton was not convicted of any offences relating to his time at this school but in civil proceedings brought against the Marist Brothers, 8 former students alleged Sutton sexually abused them. At the beginning of 1983, Sutton was transferred from Canberra to St Thomas More Primary School, Campbelltown. In 1996, he was convicted of 18 offences committed against 2 girls and 1 boy.

St Carthage's Primary School, Lismore (1983–1987)
St Carthage's Primary School in Lismore was run by the Presentation Sisters and teachers were provided by the Marist Brothers. In 1996, Sutton was convicted of 25 offences against 2 girls and 3 boys. In November 1986, Sutton was sent to Marcellin Hall, Auckland to participate in a 'personal renewal' course. Sutton told the Royal Commission the course taught him '...more appropriate adult intimacy.'

Around Easter 1987, Sutton, O'Grady and Duroux took year-5 classes on an overnight camp. Due to inclement weather, the camp was abandoned. Sutton didn't return to school that day.

O'Grady checked Sutton's diary and noted that the entry for the school camp read: ''Picked up (named redacted). What an arvo. She is magnificent. and I had a fight with (name redacted) and then we made up.''

O'Grady complained to John Kelly, director of the Lismore Catholic Education Office. Kelly formed the opinion that Sutton's behaviour was far more serious than professional negligence but did not report Sutton to the police. Instead he contacted the Provincial of the Marist Brothers, Brother Dwyer. On 30 April 1987, Sutton was finally removed from St Carthage's and placed in 'administrative leave' – a known euphemism within the Catholic Church for concealing the sexual abuse of children by a member of the clergy.

On 4 July 1987, the Marist Brothers Provincial Council met in Drummoyne. They discussed Sutton, who had been sent to Melbourne for therapy and the minutes note Sutton '...does not wish at this stage to be involved with children or schools.' Sutton was placed in the Marist Brothers House in Drummoyne, where he performed general duties. He was later offered a position at the Catholic Theological Union and worked there until July 1989.

Police investigation
In April 1989, Brother Holdsworth became aware of the suicide of one of the boys Sutton had sexually abused in the North Queensland school. The boy's father told Holdsworth that before he died, the boy disclosed that Sutton had 'interfered' with him. The father asked Holdsworth to accompany him to confront Sutton. Holdsworth accompanied the father to Sutton's residence in Hunter's Hill, Sydney.

Holdsworth gave evidence to the Royal Commission that during the meeting Sutton confessed to the boy's father he had sexually abused his son. Holdsworth conceded he wasn't sure he understood that in 1989, committing a sexual act upon a child was a crime. The boys father expressed concern that other children may have been sexually abused by Sutton.

On 11 July 1989, the New South Wales Department of Community Services received a risk of harm report concerning alleged child abuse by a Marist Brother at St Thomas More Primary School, Campbelltown, in 1984. Detective Senior Constable Donna Lawrence took statements from two school girls, alleging numerous sexual offences by Brother Sutton against them.

On 15 August 1989, the Director of the Assessment Program at the Southdown Institute in Ontario, Canada wrote to Brother Sutton stating that he would be participating in their assessment program from August 27 to September 1, 1989. Apart from being sent to Southdown, no other disciplinary action was taken against Sutton by the Marist Brothers.

Marist Brothers cover-up
Brother Turton told Sutton the police has started an investigation into Sutton's offending in Campbelltown and directed him to leave the country. Sutton left Australia three days later on 18 August 1989 and travelled to a Marist Brothers residence in Chicago. Turton also travelled to Chicago to ensure Sutton went for treatment. After seven days, Sutton travelled to the Southdown Institute in Ontario, Canada.

As NSW Police began their investigation, Detective Lawrence was told Sutton had gone overseas. Lawrence told the Royal Commission she speculated that someone had tipped off the Marist Brothers that the police were investigating Sutton.

During his hearing at the Royal Commission, Turton was asked if he had been tipped off about the NSW Police investigation by Brother Philip Slattery. Turton couldn't recall such a phone call and denied directing Sutton to leave Australia. Sutton told the Royal Commission that Turton had told him he had received a telephone call from Brother Philip Slattery, principal of Eagle Vale primary school.

In December 2017, Brother Philip Slattery pleaded guilty to four counts of indecent assault against two students.

Southdown Institute
A clinical report dated 7 December 1989, acknowledges Brother Sutton was referred to Southdown Institute '...because of sexual abuse of children.' It states that shortly before Sutton arrived at Southdown, a police investigation had already began. Sutton told his assessor that when Brother Turton was made aware of the police investigation, he directed Sutton to leave Australia and sent him to Canada.

The Southdown Institute assessment confirmed that Sutton was a paedophile with obsessive-compulsive personality disorder.

The Bart memo
Evidence presented to the Royal Commission including a document entitled 'Confidential information regarding 'Frater Bartholomew' for Mr Tony Carroll of Carrol and O'Dea dated 20 August 1989. The document set out the career of 'Bart' as a Marist Brother and teacher since 1969, including allegations of child sexual abuse from a school. In evidence, Brother Turton agreed the subject of the memo was Brother Sutton.

The Commission found the document was intended to conceal the fact the Marist Brother's were aware of serious allegations about Brother Sutton.

The United States and extradition
When Sutton's treatment ended in July 1990, he applied for dispensation from the Marist Brothers. This was granted in October 1991. Sutton signed up to study at Loyola University and resided at the Marist Brothers Chicago Community.

Sutton joined an elementary school as a lay teacher. In early 1992, Brother Turton called Sutton and told him NSW Police in Lismore had notified him that a court had issued an arrest warrant. Sutton asked Turton for advice and said that Turton told him to: ...stay there and live your life.

Sutton phoned Brother Sean Sammon, the Marist Brother Provincial in New York for advice. Sutton said Sammon repeated what Turton said to remain in the United States.

In October 1992, Sutton married his former psychiatrist and became the administrative non-teaching principal of St Dismas Elementary School, Florissant, Missouri. He held this job for two years. Sutton received a letter from Turton saying he should not be teaching in schools.

In 1995, Detective Sergeant Wayne John Magann joined an investigation involving alleged sexual assaults on former students of St Carthage's Primary School, Lismore. Magann traced Sutton to Chicago and requested an arrest warrant. Magnann contacted Detective Donna Lawrence and informed her the Sutton had been located.

On 15 August 1995, two US Federal Marshalls arrested Sutton in Missouri and charged him with 24 alleged sexual offences against 7 of his former students in Australia. On 18 August, Sutton appeared before US Magistrate Judge David Noce.

Despite an attempt to appeal the extradition, the Supreme Court of the United States ruled against him and Sutton was extradited to Australia on 29 April 1996. Magnann took Sutton to Sydney Police Centre, where he interviewed him. Sutton was charged and bail was refused.

On 26 May 1996, Sutton was charged with 39 additional offences and during the interview confessed to the crimes he had been extradited for and revealed further offences against 9 additional children.

1996 trial and imprisonment
On 2 August 1996, Sutton pleaded guilty to a total of 67 child sex offences in relation to 15 student at schools in New South Wales:
 * 13 counts of sexual intercourse with a child under 16 years
 * 53 counts of indecent assault or an act of indecency
 * One count of gross indecency

Brother Sutton was sentenced on 8 November 1996 to 18 years imprisonment, with a minimum term of 13 and a half years. In December 2000, his sentence was reduced on appeal to 15 years, with a minimum of 12 years. In total, Sutton has been the subject of allegations of child sexual abuse by 27 of his former students. A Non-Publication Order was granted and remained in place until Sutton gave evidence at the Royal Commission in 2014.

An appeal was rejected on 6 December 2000 in the NSW Court of Criminal Appeal. Sutton spent a decade on strict non-association confinement at Goulburn Correctional Centre before being transferred to the CUBIT program at Long Bay.

Following the successful completion of the CUBIT program, Sutton was released from prison on 4 April 2008.

The Royal Commission Into Institutional Responses to Child Sexual Abuse
On Tuesday 1 July 2014 Gregory Sutton was called to give evidence to the Royal Commission Into Institutional Responses to Child Sexual Abuse. Sutton told the Commission Brother Alexis Turton told him he was under investigation by NSW Police and directed him to leave the country.

The Commission findings included:


 * 154 Marist Brothers were officially accused of child sexual abuse in Australia between 1980–2015.
 * 20% of the Marist Brothers between 1950 and 2010 were paedophiles.
 * Claims of abuse against the Marist Brothers account for a quarter of all claims received by religious institutions.
 * 486 people made a claim of abuse against the Marist Brothers between 1980 and 2015.
 * The average age of claimants at the time of their abuse was 12.

An internal Marist Brothers document showed that at least 10 Marist Brothers had admitted their sexual offending to Brother Turton. Turton told the Commission he had talked to 52 of the 154 alleged offenders between 1989 and 2012. The commission revealed that the Marist Brothers had used special codes for alleged offenders in their internal communications.

In 2017, Sutton was given a suspended sentence of two years and two months for offences against 2 Canberra boys in the 1980s. Sutton pleaded guilty in the ACT Supreme Court but could not be charged because of a statute of limitations.

The Marist Brothers provided the Royal Commission with a summary of all claims for compensation or redress concerning child sexual abuse by Brother Gregory Sutton.

In total, the Marist Brothers received 21 claims with respect to Sutton. Of the 21 claims:
 * 8 were from former students of Marist College Canberra.
 * The Marist Brothers paid a total of $1,817,811 to claimants
 * 17 claims were settled out of court, with an average settlement amount of $105,459.47
 * 2 claims have been processed under Towards Healing, with one claimant receiving a financial payment of $25,000

The legal costs for claims settled by the Marist Brothers were $62,545.24 (plus $15,337.99 in disbursements) for civil claims concerning Brother Sutton.

The legal costs of Catholic Church Insurance were $250,888.25 for civil claims concerning Brother Sutton.