Lesley Eugene Warren

Lesley Eugene Warren (born October 15, 1967), known as The Babyface Killer, is an American serial killer who murdered at least three women in North and South Carolina from 1989 to 1990. Convicted and sentenced to death for the murders in North Carolina, he later confessed to five additional murders, including one in New York, but was never charged with them.

Early life
Lesley Eugene Warren was born on October 15, 1967, in Candler, North Carolina, the older of two sons born to Douglas Eugene Warren and Phyllis West. Reportedly, he began to exhibit signs of antisocial behavior from an early age and was diagnosed with autism at the age of three. As a child, he struggled with establishing emotional connections with the people around him, which further worsened after the birth of his brother Laron Ray in 1970.

Following the birth of his second son, Warren's father began to struggle financially and would begin to physically abuse his family. In 1971, he set fire to the family's trailer that almost killed his wife and one of the boys. After the incident, Phyllis divorced him and moved in with relatives, accompanied by the children. Douglas continued to stalk and harass her, which resulted in Phyllis being awarded full custody of their two children and being granted a restraining order against her ex-husband.

In September 1974, Lesley began attending the Emma Elementary School in Candler, where he often clashed with classmates and was often sent to the school's psychologist. During his school years, he had no interest in learning and did not participate in sports, which made him unpopular among his peers. By 1981, Warren began attending Erwin High School - shortly afterwards, he began arguing with his mother, which caused him to be stressed out and further impacted his academic performance. After having several conversations with the teenager, the school psychologist suggested that Warren undergo psychotherapy.

By the end of 1981, his mental condition deteriorated rapidly. At around the same time, Warren began spending much of his free time with petty criminals, with he himself soon engaging in burglaries, doing drugs and threatening peers with physical violence. In January 1982, he was arrested for vandalism and expelled from school, whereupon he was placed in the Broughton Hospital for a psychological evaluation. Based on the results of the evaluation, Warren was diagnosed with a schizoid personality disorder and was prescribed treatment, which supposedly improved his mental health. He was soon discharged and enrolled at Enka High School in September 1982, but was expelled 33 days later because he failed to attend for 20 school days. In early October, his mother discovered marijuana in his room, and after arguing about it, Warren was thrown out of the house for the night.

Assault on Betty Pressley
On the following day, Warren returned to his mother's house, and while she was away, he abducted the next-door neighbor Betty Pressley and dragged her to the basement, where he tied her up. At this point, Pressley's friend showed up to the house, but as he was unable to find her, he went around searching until he found her in the basement. A struggle ensued between him and Warren, in which the latter shot the former with a revolver and then fled the scene. The injury proved to be non-fatal, allowing the friend to free Pressley from her restraints and call the police.

Warren was arrested for this crime on October 4, 1982. He admitted responsibility during questioning, and was then placed in the Buncombe County Detention Center to await trial. Just a month after his arrest, he attempted to hang himself in his cell but failed, after which Warren was placed in a psychiatric hospital to undergo treatment. After his mental health improved, he was convicted of kidnapping Pressley and the attempted murder of her friend, but as a juvenile, he received a minor sentence and was sent to the Juvenile Evaluation Center, where he remained until October 1985.

Upon his release, Warren returned to Candler, where he resided with his mother. On April 4, 1986, he enlisted in the United States Army and was stationed at Fort Benning, Georgia, where he soon attained the rank of Specialist. While there, he married a girl named Tracy Bradshaw, who bore him two sons. In late 1986, Warren was assigned to the 10th Mountain Division, after which he was transferred to Fort Drum in New York.

Patsy Vineyard
On May 15, 1987, 20-year-old Patsy Diane Vineyard, the wife of one of Warren's colleagues stationed at Fort Drum, was murdered. In mid-May, Michael Vineyard was sent away to partake in a field maneuvers exercise, after which Warren began an affair with his wife. On May 15, while on a date together and using drugs, he raped and strangled her, after which he threw the corpse into the Black River near Sackets Harbor. Her body was found floating in Lake Ontario a month later. On February 25, 1988, Warren was apprehended by a military unit for going AWOL, for which he was incarcerated for 75 days and demoted to PFC. On April 28, he was ordered to continue military service at Fort Benjamin Harrison, Indiana, but upon learning of this, Warren left and instead went to New York City, where he spent the summer living in homeless shelters and became addicted to drugs.

On June 17, Warren was dishonorably discharged from the Army and labeled a deserter. At the end of the month, he left New York for Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, where he was arrested on vagrancy charges. After serving a sentence at the local jail, he moved with his wife and child to Spartanburg, South Carolina in the fall of 1988. Warren soon began frequently arguing with his wife due to his drug addiction, which soon caused him to abandon them and return to Candler. Once there, he found work as a cashier at a store near his mother's house and enrolled in a 3-month training program for truck drivers. He was described as living a punk lifestyle and liked to listen to acid rock.

Carolina murders
On March 10, 1989, Warren completed the program and took on a job as a driver for Am-Can, a trucking company based in Anderson, South Carolina. That summer he briefly reunited with his wife before she returned to Spartanburg. She later revealed to him that she was pregnant with their second child, and that she intended to file for divorce so she could receive child support.

On August 26, Warren came across 42-year-old Velma Faye Gray, who had just suffered a traffic accident on the road just five miles away from her hometown, Travelers Rest. Under the pretense of helping her, he lured her into his truck and drove to a nearby wooded area where he beat and strangled her to death. After this, he threw her body into Lake Bowen, where it was later found by two fishermen. Her car was later found in Greenville County, but it was determined to be stolen by an individual unconnected to Gray's murder.

On December 25, he met 39-year-old Jayme Denise Hurley, a counselor at the Juvenile Evaluation Center in Swannanoa, with whom he began an intimate relationship. On May 24, 1990, after sharing crack cocaine together, Warren physically assaulted and strangled Hurley to death. On the following day, he confessed this act to his brother Laron, who then helped him bury the body in a snake-infested pit located within the Pisgah National Forest. Two days later, Hurley's father contacted the police about his daughter's disappearance and told them that her boyfriend Lesley was the last person to see her alive. On May 28, Warren was taken into custody, but denied any involvement with her disappearance. Police eventually found her purse in his car, but as the body had not been found yet, he was only charged with misdemeanor larceny and failure to produce a title to a motor vehicle.

On June 6, Warren's grandfather paid his $1,000 bail and he was released pending trial. During this time, he confessed to his wife that he had murdered Hurley, and to his mother that he had murdered Vineyard. Two days later, his mother called the police and relayed what her son had told her, at which point he was declared the prime suspect in the killing. The trial for the theft of Hurley's purse began on July 10, 1990, but on the following day, Warren stole a black-gray Kawasaki motorcycle and fled across the state.

On July 13, he met cocktail waitress Teri Quinby in High Point, where he was staying at the Radisson Hotel. He was previously acquainted with her, as he had played with her brother for a local amateur softball team and had been to their house. Two days later, he was invited to a picnic attended by Quinby, her children and friends. While there, he met a friend of Quinby's, 21-year-old Katherine Nowell Johnson, a part-time student at the University of North Carolina. After drinking alcohol together, Warren and Johnson went for a ride on his motorcycle. On the afternoon of July 16, he brought her to an abandoned soccer field where he raped and strangled her with her own bra. He then placed Johnson's body inside her car, parked it in the garage, and then fled on foot. The body was soon discovered by the staff, who immediately contacted the police.

Arrest
On July 7, a press conference was held in which Warren was announced a suspect in at least four murders. Soon after this, they were contacted by his brother, who admitted to helping Lesley dispose of Hurley's corpse and then showed them they had buried it. In the meantime, Lesley himself was arrested on July 21 at Quinby's house by police officers, offering no resistance.

Following his arrest, he admitted responsibility to the murders and openly cooperated with the authorities. He also said that in addition to these four, he was responsible for another four murders that he had not been connected to. According to him, in August 1988, he killed a Hispanic girl named Mary and buried her body in a peach orchard in Campobello, South Carolina; in the summer of 1989, he picked a male hitchhiker named Ronald, killed him and then buried his body in Tennessee. The two other murders supposedly occurred in 1989 in Asheville, when he killed two men during a drug deal. When asked about the Hurley murder, Warren insisted that he did not intend to kill her and that she died of an accidental drug overdose.

Trials and sentences
Following his arrest, Warren was charged with the four murders he had been conclusively linked to. In late 1990, a number of high-ranking law enforcement officials from North Carolina, South Carolina and New York met to plan a strategy for prosecuting Warren, with the final decision being that he first be extradited to South Carolina to face charges for the murder of Velma Gray, and then to North Carolina for the remaining murders.

On August 23, 1991, Warren was extradited to South Carolina. At the request of his attorneys, he underwent a psychiatric evaluation, which ruled him sane in April 1992. His trial began on April 13, 1993, and only lasted two days, as he pleaded guilty and was subsequently sentenced to life imprisonment. After this, he was extradited to North Carolina, where he stood trial for the murder of Hurley in early 1995. Based on the incriminating evidence and his own confession, Warren was found guilty on all counts and was sentenced to death on October 6, 1995. After the trial ended, the Deputy District Attorney from New York stated that while he remained the prime suspect in the murder of Vineyard, he would not be tried due to his death sentence in North Carolina.

In early 1996, Warren was put on trial for the murder of Katherine Johnson. He was found guilty in late March, and after deliberating for 75 minutes, the jury recommended that he be sentenced to death again. During sentencing, Warren retained complete composure and showed no emotion, while throughout the trial, his attorneys had argued that he was drunk at the time of the murders and thus the charges should have been downgraded to second-degree murder.

Appeals and current status
After his conviction, Warren was transferred to North Carolina's death row in Central Prison, Raleigh. In cooperation with his attorneys, he filed an appeal to overturn his death sentence, but it was denied in 1998. In 2009, he was among the 147 inmates who filed petitions under the newly imposed Racial Justice Act, under the justification that the sentence was unjust as he was more likely to be sentenced to death due to the fact that his victims were white. However, his petition was ultimately denied, as the appellate court found that he had received a fair trial and there was no presence of racial bias that could have affected his sentencing.

In 2014, his case was covered on an episode of the true crime documentary Handsome Devils, on Investigation Discovery.

As of November 2023, Warren remains on death row and awaits execution, as he is among the inmates who have completely exhausted their appeals.