List of All-Conference USA men's soccer teams

The Conference USA Men's Soccer All-Conference Team is an annual selection of the best overall players in Conference USA during the NCAA Division I men's soccer season. Selections are based on a vote by the head coaches and announced the day prior to the Conference Tournament. The teams are divided into First, Second, and Third All-Conference Teams

2014
First-Team All-Conference USA
 * GK: Callum Irving, Kentucky
 * D: Biko Bradnock-Brennan, Charlotte
 * D: Jordan Wilson, Kentucky
 * D: Darion Copeland, UAB
 * MF: Brandt Bronico, Charlotte
 * MF: Napo Matsoso, Kentucky
 * MF: Ben McKendry, New Mexico
 * MF: Chris Wehan, New Mexico
 * F: Kyle Parker, Charlotte
 * F: Quentin Albrecht, FIU
 * F: Freddy Ruiz, UAB

Second-Team All-Conference USA
 * GK: Austin Pack, Charlotte
 * D: Mathew Gibbons, New Mexico
 * D: Nick Miele, New Mexico
 * D: Mahamoudou Kaba, South Carolina
 * D: Braeden Troyer, South Carolina
 * MF: Nate Foglesong, Old Dominion
 * MF: Alex Clay, UAB
 * F: Justin Laird, Kentucky
 * F: Daniel Jodah, Marshall
 * F: James Rogers, New Mexico
 * F: Mikkel Knudsen, South Carolina

Third-Team All-Conference USA
 * GK: Alex Tiesenhausen, Old Dominion
 * D: Marvin Hezel, FIU
 * D: Ian Svantesson, UAB
 * MF: Dominic Bonilla, Charlotte
 * MF: Daniel Gonzalez, FIU
 * MF: Kristoffer Tollefsen, Kentucky
 * MF: Nick Edginton, Marshall
 * MF: Ryan Condotta, Old Dominion
 * MF: Kurtis Turner, South Carolina
 * F: Monbo Bokar, Charlotte
 * F: Ryan Price, FAU
 * F: Niko Hansen, New Mexico
 * F: Jesse Miralrio, Old Dominion

2013
First-Team All-Conference USA
 * GK: Callum Irving, Kentucky
 * D: Kyle Venter, New Mexico
 * D: Jason Gaylord, Old Dominion
 * D: Mahamoudou Kaba, South Carolina
 * MF: Aidan Kirkbride, Charlotte
 * MF: Michael Calderon, New Mexico
 * MF: Ben McKendry, New Mexico
 * MF: Omar Mata, Tulsa
 * F: Giuseppe Gentile, Charlotte
 * F: Tim Hokinson, Old Dominion
 * F: Cristian Mata, Tulsa
 * F: Freddy Ruiz, UAB

Second-Team All-Conference USA
 * GK: Sean Stowe, Old Dominion
 * D: Thomas Allen, Charlotte
 * D: Steven Perinovic, Kentucky
 * D: Mathew Gibbons, New Mexico
 * D: Braeden Troyer, South Carolina
 * MF: Gonzalo Frechilla, FIU
 * MF: Brad Doliner, Kentucky
 * MF: Akeil Barrett, Tulsa
 * MF: Alex Clay, UAB
 * F: Quentin Albrecht, FIU
 * F: Diego Navarette, UAB

Third-Team All-Conference USA
 * GK: Michael Lisch, New Mexico
 * GK: Raphael Ville, UAB
 * D: Travis Brent, Marshall
 * D: Bradley Bourgeois, Tulsa
 * D: Darion Copeland, UAB
 * MF: Zach Hunter, Marshall
 * MF: Michael Kafari, New Mexico
 * MF: Tony Rocha, Tulsa
 * F: Kyle Parker, Charlotte
 * F: Ryan Price, FAU
 * F: James Rogers, New Mexico

2012
First-Team All-Conference USA
 * GK: Daniel Withrow, Marshall
 * GK: Jaime Ibarra, SMU
 * D: Steven Perinovic, Kentucky
 * D: Mladen Lemez, UAB
 * D: Andrew Quintana, UCF
 * MF: Matt Lodge, Kentucky
 * MF: Liam Collins, Memphis
 * MF: Omar Mata, Tulsa
 * F: Mark Sherrod, Memphis
 * F: Cristian Mata, Tulsa
 * F: Deshorn Brown, UCF

Second-Team All-Conference USA
 * GK: Jack Van Arsdale, Kentucky
 * D: Damien Rosales, SMU
 * D: Aaron Simmons, SMU
 * D: Darion Copeland, UAB
 * D: Reed Matte, UAB
 * D: Ben Hunt, UCF
 * MF: Cameron Wilder, Kentucky
 * MF: T.J. Nelson, SMU
 * MF: Braeden Troyer, South Carolina
 * F: Quentin Albrecht, FIU
 * F: Tom Jackson, Marshall
 * F: Tyler Engel, SMU
 * F: Bradlee Baladez, South Carolina
 * F: Kofi Gyawu, UAB

Third-Team All-Conference USA
 * GK: Mark Pais, Tulsa
 * D: Joseph Dawkins, FIU
 * D: Anthony Hobbs, FIU
 * D: Dylan Asher, Kentucky
 * D: Jordan Johnson, Memphis
 * D: Mike Mangotic, South Carolina
 * D: Tony Rocha, Tulsa
 * MF: Daniel Gonzalez, FIU
 * MF: Devin Perkins, Marshall
 * MF: Andrew Morales, SMU
 * MF: Fatai Alabi, UAB
 * MF: Chase Wickham, UAB
 * MF: Omar Vallejo, UCF
 * F: Tyler Riggs, Kentucky

2011
First-Team All-Conference USA
 * GK: Daniel Withrow, Marshall
 * D: Anthony Hobbs, FIU
 * D: Diogo de Almeida, SMU
 * D: Andrew Quintana, UCF
 * MF: Liam Collins, Memphis
 * MF: Warren Creavalle, UCF
 * MF: Kevan George, UCF
 * F: Mark Sherrod, Memphis
 * F: Arthur Ivo, SMU
 * F: Bradlee Baladez, South Carolina
 * F: Babayele Sodade, UAB

Second-Team All-Conference USA
 * GK: Carl Woszczynski, UAB
 * D: Dylan Asher, Kentucky
 * D: J.J. Greer, Memphis
 * D: Reed Matte, UAB
 * MF: Tom Jackson, Marshall
 * MF: Anthony Virgara, Marshall
 * MF: T.J. Nelson, SMU
 * MF: Stephen Morrissey, South Carolina
 * MF: Omar Mata, Tulsa
 * F: Juan Castillo, SMU
 * F: Corey Albertson, Tulsa

Third-Team All-Conference USA
 * GK: Conor Hurley, Memphis
 * D: Danny Cates, South Carolina
 * D: Blaine Gonsalves, Tulsa
 * D: Mladen Lemez, UAB
 * MF: Braeden Troyer, South Carolina
 * MF: Tony Rocha, Tulsa
 * MF: Nik Robson, UCF
 * F: Quentin Albrecht, FIU
 * F: Matt Lodge, Kentucky
 * F: Tyler Riggs, Kentucky
 * F: McKauly Tulloch, UCF

2010
First-Team All-Conference USA
 * GK: Daniel Withrow, Marshall
 * D: Will Traynor, South Carolina
 * D: Justin Chavez, Tulsa
 * D: Hunter Christiansen, Tulsa
 * D: Curtis Ushedo, UAB
 * D: Kevan George, UCF
 * MF: Arthur Ivo, SMU
 * MF: Ashley McInnes, Tulsa
 * MF: Warren Creavalle, UCF
 * F: Blake Brettschneider, South Carolina
 * F: Nik Robson, UCF

Second-Team All-Conference USA
 * GK: Jimmy Maurer, South Carolina
 * D: Anthony Hobbs, FIU
 * D: Dylan Asher, Kentucky
 * D: Jordan Hilgefort, Marshall
 * D: Leone Cruz, SMU
 * D: Yaron Bacher, UCF
 * MF: Matt Lodge, Kentucky
 * MF: Kekoa Osorio, SMU
 * MF: Josue Soto, SMU
 * F: Juan Castillo, SMU
 * F: Babayele Sodade, UAB

Third-Team All-Conference USA
 * GK: Tyler Beadle, Kentucky
 * GK: Carl Woszczynski, UAB
 * GK: Shawn Doyle, UCF
 * D: Nicholas Chase, FIU
 * D: Kendall Sutton, Marshall
 * D: Chris Taylor, Tulsa
 * MF: Sammy Boateng, Marshall
 * MF: Michal Mravec, UAB
 * F: Michael Muehseler, FIU
 * F: Tyler Riggs, Kentucky
 * F: Tom Jackson, Marshall
 * F: Bradlee Baladez, South Carolina
 * F: Austin Neil, Tulsa
 * F: Kofi Gyawu, UAB

2009
First-Team All-Conference USA
 * GK: Carl Woszczynski, UAB
 * D: Barry Rice, Kentucky
 * D: Tyler Ruthven, South Carolina
 * D: Justin Chavez, Tulsa
 * MF: Jason Griffiths, Kentucky
 * MF: Dustin Dawes, Marshall
 * MF: Dane Saintus, SMU
 * MF: Ashley McInnes, Tulsa
 * F: Sam Arthur, South Carolina
 * F: Austin Neil, Tulsa
 * F: Two-Boys Gumede, UAB

Second-Team All-Conference USA
 * GK: Dan Williams, Kentucky
 * GK: Daniel Withrow, Marshall
 * D: Rick Alleman, Memphis
 * D: Chris Taylor, Tulsa
 * D: Curtis Ushedo, UAB
 * MF: Payton Hickey, SMU
 * MF: Yaron Bacher, UCF
 * MF: Kevan George, UCF
 * F: Matt Lodge, Kentucky
 * F: Jose Parada, Tulsa
 * F: Babayele Sodade, UAB

Third-Team All-Conference USA
 * GK: Jimmy Maurer, South Carolina
 * D: Anthony Hobbs, FIU
 * D: Brad Walker, Kentucky
 * D: Kendall Sutton, Marshall
 * D: Andreas Guenther, Memphis
 * D: Ian Kalis, SMU
 * MF: Matt Butler, Marshall
 * MF: Kekoa Osorio, SMU
 * MF: Hunter Christiansen, Tulsa
 * MF: Michal Mravec, UAB
 * F: Steven Cabas, FIU
 * F: Sebastian Frings, FIU
 * F: Blake Brettschneider, South Carolina
 * F: Nicholas Robson, UCF

2008
First-Team All-Conference USA
 * GK: Tyrel Lacey, Tulsa
 * D: Barry Rice, Kentucky
 * D: Michael Coburn, Memphis
 * D: Chris Taylor, Tulsa
 * MF: Jason Griffiths, Kentucky
 * MF: Joe Salem, Tulsa
 * MF: Two-Boys Gumede, UAB
 * MF: Kevan George, UCF
 * F: Juan Guerra, FIU
 * F: Sam Arthur, South Carolina
 * F: Blake Brettschneider, South Carolina

Second-Team All-Conference USA
 * GK: Jimmy Maurer, South Carolina
 * D: Tyler Ruthven, South Carolina
 * D: Chris Clements, Tulsa
 * D: Ryan Roushandel, UCF
 * MF: Leone Cruz, SMU
 * MF: Jeff Harwell, SMU
 * MF: Kekoa Osorio, SMU
 * MF: Jeff Scanella, South Carolina
 * F: Paulo da Silva, SMU
 * F: Ashley McInnes, Tulsa
 * F: Austin Neil, Tulsa

Third-Team All-Conference USA
 * GK: Dan Williams, Kentucky
 * D: Philip Fisher, FIU
 * D: Mark Wiltse, South Carolina
 * D: Dean Sorrell, UAB
 * MF: Masumi Turnbull, Kentucky
 * MF: Jira Cooley, Marshall
 * MF: Trey Gergory, UAB
 * MF: Michal Mrevec, UAB
 * F: Sterling Flunder, Marshall
 * F: Parker Duncan, Memphis
 * F: Jose Parada, Tulsa

2007
First-Team All-Conference USA
 * GK: Dominic Cervi, Tulsa
 * D: Barry Rice, Kentucky
 * D: Adrian Chevannes, SMU
 * D: Chris Clements, Tulsa
 * MF: Bruno Guarda, SMU
 * MF: Ben Shuleva, SMU
 * MF: Jeff Scanella, South Carolina
 * MF: Eric DeFreitas, Tulsa
 * F: Juan Guerra, FIU
 * F: Jose Parada, Tulsa
 * F: Dejan Jakovic, UAB

Second-Team All-Conference USA
 * GK: Jimmy Maurer, South Carolina
 * D: Jeff Lenix, Marshall
 * D: Michael Coburn, Memphis
 * D: Ryan Mirsky, SMU
 * MF: Masumi Turnbull, Kentucky
 * MF: Sterling Flounder, Marshall
 * MF: Adam Montgomery, Memphis
 * MF: Trey Gregory, UAB
 * F: Jared Britcher, Memphis
 * F: Dane Saintus, SMU
 * F: Ryan Roushandel, UCF

Third-Team All-Conference USA
 * GK: Steve Sandbo, SMU
 * D: Raoul Voss, FIU
 * D: Tyler Ruthven, South Carolina
 * D: Mark Wiltse, South Carolina
 * MF: John Daniele, Marshall
 * MF: Sean Goulding, Memphis
 * MF: Scott Corbin, SMU
 * MF: Jeff Harwell, SMU
 * F: Aaron Swanson, Kentucky
 * F: Eric Burkholder, Tulsa
 * F: Todd Goddard, Tulsa

2006
First-Team All-Conference USA
 * GK: Matt Wideman, SMU
 * D: Mynor Gonzalez, SMU
 * D: Jay Needham, SMU
 * D: Ryan Leeton, South Carolina
 * MF: Mike D’Agostino, Kentucky
 * MF: Bruno Guarda, SMU
 * MF: Chase Wileman, SMU
 * MF: Dejan Jakovic, UAB
 * F: Riley O’Neill, Kentucky
 * F: Mike Sambursky, South Carolina
 * F: Jerson Monteiro, UAB

Second-Team All-Conference USA
 * GK: Mike Gustavson, South Carolina
 * D: Nathan Marks, Kentucky
 * D: Jeff Lenix, Marshall
 * D: Makan Hislop, South Carolina
 * MF: Kevin Walsh, Memphis
 * MF: Ralph Pace, South Carolina
 * MF: Matt Thomas, Tulsa
 * MF: Two-Boys Gumede, UAB
 * F: David Hope, FIU
 * F: Adrian Chevannes, SMU
 * F: Jose Parada, Tulsa
 * F: Zak Boggs, UCF

Third-Team All-Conference USA
 * GK: Dan Williams, Kentucky
 * D: Jamie Gilbert, Memphis
 * D: Ryan Mirsky, SMU
 * D: Chris Clements, Tulsa
 * MF: Dadi Kristjánsson, FIU
 * MF: Masumi Turnbull, Kentucky
 * MF: Ben Shuleva, SMU
 * MF: Jeff Scannella, South Carolina
 * F: Karim Boukhemis, Marshall
 * F: Ayo Akinsete, South Carolina
 * F: Eric Burkholder, Tulsa

2005
First-Team All-Conference USA
 * GK: Andy Gruenebaum, Kentucky
 * D: Thomas Senecal, Kentucky
 * D: Jay Needham, SMU
 * D: Greg Reece, South Carolina
 * MF: Lucas Scudeler, FIU
 * MF: Dayton O’Brien, Memphis
 * MF: David Chun, SMU
 * MF: Mike Sambursky, South Carolina
 * F: Duke Hashimoto, SMU
 * F: Josh Alcala, South Carolina
 * F: Kyle Brown, Tulsa

Second-Team All-Conference USA
 * GK: Mike Gustavson, South Carolina
 * D: Brandon Stewart, Kentucky
 * D: Jeff Lenix, Marshall
 * D: Dejan Jakovic, UAB
 * MF: Karim Boukhemis, Marshall
 * MF: Kellan Zindel, SMU
 * MF: Matt Wiley, Tulsa
 * MF: Sandy Gbandi, UAB
 * F: Carron Williams, FIU
 * F: Andy Metcalf, Memphis
 * F: Jason McLaughlin, UAB

Third-Team All-Conference USA
 * GK: A.J. Robles, UAB
 * D: Mynor Gonzalez, SMU
 * D: Ryan Leeton, South Carolina
 * D: Jamie Dabney, Tulsa
 * MF: Jared Rose, FIU
 * MF: Mike D’Agostino, Kentucky
 * MF: Bruno Guarda, SMU
 * MF: Ralph Pace, South Carolina
 * MF: Eric Burkholder, Tulsa
 * F: Maurice Hughes, UAB
 * F: Jerson Monteiro, UAB
 * F: Billy Judino, UCF

2004
First-Team All-Conference USA
 * GK: Sebastian Vecchio, Memphis
 * D: Justin Dyer, Memphis
 * D: Sandi Gbandi, UAB
 * D: Kareem Smith, USF
 * MF: Floyd Franks, Charlotte
 * MF: Daniel Dobson, Memphis
 * MF: John DiRaimondo, Saint Louis
 * MF: Ryan Wileman, Saint Louis
 * MF: Leandro de Oliveira, UAB
 * F: Adam Ruud, Charlotte
 * F: Dayton O’Brien, Memphis
 * F: Will John, Saint Louis

Second-Team All-Conference USA
 * GK: Dane Brenner, USF
 * D: Matt Neeley, Louisville
 * D: Brett Branan, Saint Louis
 * D: Tim Ward, Saint Louis
 * MF: Jeff Hughes, Cincinnati
 * MF: John Liersemann, Cincinnati
 * MF: Keeron Benito, USF
 * MF: Simon Schoendorf, USF
 * F: Wiremu Patrick, Cincinnati
 * F: Chris Lee, Marquette
 * F: Andy Metcalf, Memphis

Third-Team All-Conference USA
 * GK: Mike Vessels, Cincinnati
 * D: John Nabers, Charlotte
 * D: Ewen Blair, Cincinnati
 * D: Gary Connolly, Memphis
 * D: Joe Klosterman, UAB
 * MF: John Kornfeld, DePaul
 * MF: Bryan Dahlquist, Marquette
 * MF: John Reilly, Memphis
 * MF: Rogerio Oliveira, UAB
 * F: Terron Amos, East Carolina
 * F: David Guzman, Louisville
 * F: Rodrigo Hidalgo, USF
 * F: Hunter West, USF

2003
First-Team All-Conference USA
 * GK: Brad Sokolowski, Louisville
 * D: Adrian Cann, Louisville
 * D: Nick Gannon, Saint Louis
 * D: Tony McManus, UAB
 * MF: Tim Brown, Cincinnati
 * MF: Josh Gardner, Cincinnati
 * MF: Leandro de Oliveira, UAB
 * MF: Marin Pusek, UAB
 * F: Simon Bird, Louisville
 * F: Chris Lee, Marquette
 * F: Vedad Ibišević, Saint Louis

Second-Team All-Conference USA
 * GK: Martin Hutton, Saint Louis
 * D: Anders Cedergren, Cincinnati
 * D: Brandon Dobbs, Cincinnati
 * D: Andy Pusateri, Saint Louis
 * MF: Floyd Franks, Charlotte
 * MF: Dayton O’Brien, Memphis
 * MF: John DiRaimondo, Saint Louis
 * MF: Brian Grazier, Saint Louis
 * F: Mira Mupier, Charlotte
 * F: Andy Metcalf, Memphis
 * F: Will John, Saint Louis

Third-Team All-Conference USA
 * GK: John Adams, Cincinnati
 * D: Joe Lampert, Charlotte
 * D: Matt Neely, Louisville
 * D: Graham Gibbs, Memphis
 * MF: Clyde Simms, East Carolina
 * MF: Cooper McKee, Saint Louis
 * MF: Nnamdi Ngwe, UAB
 * MF: Keeron Benito, USF
 * F: Derek Guiterrez, Marquette
 * F: Jerson Monteiro, UAB
 * F: Hunter West, USF

2002
First-Team All-Conference USA
 * GK: Clint Baumstark, UAB
 * D: Adrian Cann, Louisville
 * D: Steve Lawrence, Marquette
 * D: Nick Gannon, Saint Louis
 * MF: Joe Hammes, Saint Louis
 * MF: Jack Jewsbury, Saint Louis
 * MF: Marin Pusek, UAB
 * MF: Jeff Thwaites, USF
 * F: Jason Cole, Saint Louis
 * F: Flavio Monteiro, UAB
 * F: Hunter West, USF

Second-Team All-Conference USA
 * GK: Troy Perkins, USF
 * D: Chris Schmidt, Memphis
 * D: Kevin Wickart, Saint Louis
 * D: Jared Vock, USF
 * MF: Tim Brown, Cincinnati
 * MF: Josh Gardner, Cincinnati
 * MF: Mike Robards, Marquette
 * MF: Nick Walls, Saint Louis
 * F: Mira Mupier, Charlotte
 * F: Simon Bird, Louisville
 * F: Derek Gutierrez, Marquette

Third-Team All-Conference USA
 * GK: Martin Hutton, Saint Louis
 * D: Brandon Dobbs, Cincinnati
 * D: Tom Nolan, Marquette
 * D: Tony McManus, UAB
 * MF: Shane Carew, Charlotte
 * MF: Clyde Simms, East Carolina
 * MF: Fernando Tolomelli, Louisville
 * MF: Mike Kirchhoff, Saint Louis
 * F: Wiremu Patrick, Cincinnati
 * F: Luke Rojo, DePaul
 * F: Eric Marshall, Marquette

2001
First-Team All-Conference USA
 * GK: John Politis, Saint Louis
 * D: Adrian Cann, Louisville
 * D: Jason Cole, Saint Louis
 * D: Marty Tappel, Saint Louis
 * MF: Sean Reti, Marquette
 * MF: Brad Davis, Saint Louis
 * MF: Mike Hill, Saint Louis
 * MF: Jeff Thwaites, USF
 * F: Sean Fraser, Memphis
 * F: Dipsy Selolwane, Saint Louis
 * F: Jason Cudjoe, USF

Second-Team All-Conference USA
 * GK: Lucas Mackanos, Charlotte
 * D: Steve Lawrence, Marquette
 * D: Brantley Spillman, UAB
 * D: Jared Vock, USF
 * MF: Justin Stralka, Memphis
 * MF: David Beck, Saint Louis
 * MF: Nelson Mata, UAB
 * MF: Marin Pusek, UAB
 * F: Jack Jewsbury, Saint Louis
 * F: Flavio Monteiro, UAB
 * F: Martin Rey, UAB

Third-Team All-Conference USA
 * GK: Clint Baumstark, UAB
 * GK: Troy Perkins, USF
 * D: Shane Carew, Charlotte
 * D: Stephen Lewis, Memphis
 * D: Bubba Garcia, UAB
 * MF: Bryan Godfrey, Marquette
 * MF: Mike Kirchoff, Saint Louis
 * MF: Nick Baker, TCU
 * MF: Gabriel Salgado, USF
 * F: Juan Munoz-Airey, Charlotte
 * F: Simon Bird, Louisville
 * F: Lars Thorstensen, Memphis

2000
First-Team All-Conference USA
 * GK: David Clemente, UAB
 * D: Adrian Cann, Louisville
 * D: Joe Hammes, Saint Louis
 * D: Rumbani Munthali, UAB
 * MF: Ryan Schreck, Cincinnati
 * MF: Shawn Faria, Louisville
 * MF: Sean Reti, Marquette
 * MF: Brad Davis, Saint Louis
 * F: Myron Vaughn, Cincinnati
 * F: Sean Fraser, Memphis
 * F: Jack Jewsbury, Saint Louis

Second-Team All-Conference USA
 * GK: John Politis, Saint Louis
 * D: Jamal Frazier, Cincinnati
 * D: Stephen Lewis, Memphis
 * D: Jason Cole, Saint Louis
 * MF: David McGill, Charlotte
 * MF: Stuart Langrish, Louisville
 * MF: Justin Stralka, Memphis
 * MF: Mike Hill, Saint Louis
 * F: C.J. Robinson, Charlotte
 * F: Marshall Morehead, Marquette
 * F: Greg Krauss, USF

Third-Team All-Conference USA
 * GK: Jeremy Morales, Louisville
 * D: Sean Carew, Charlotte
 * D: Ntando Tsambo, Charlotte
 * D: Steve Lawrence, Marquette
 * MF: David Pedreschi, Charlotte
 * MF: Andy Hunter, Marquette
 * MF: Marty Tappel, Saint Louis
 * MF: Roberto Najarro, UAB
 * MF: Houston Smith, UAB
 * F: Juan Munoz-Airey, Charlotte
 * F: Shane Hudson, DePaul
 * F: Lars Thorstensen, Memphis

1999
First-Team All-Conference USA
 * GK: Paul Nagy, Saint Louis
 * D: Andrew Kean, Cincinnati
 * D: Rumbani Munthali, UAB
 * D: Brian Alvero, USF
 * MF: Ryan Schreck, Cincinnati
 * MF: Sean Reti, Marquette
 * MF: Jeff DiMaria, Saint Louis
 * MF: Jason Mims, Saint Louis
 * F: Marshall Morehead, Marquette
 * F: Peter Byaruhanga, UAB
 * F: Kevin Alvero, USF

Second-Team All-Conference USA
 * GK: David Clemente, UAB
 * D: C.J. Robinson, Charlotte
 * D: Jason Cole, Saint Louis
 * D: David Williams, Saint Louis
 * MF: Jamath Shoffner, Charlotte
 * MF: Shawn Faria, Louisville
 * MF: Andy Hunter, Marquette
 * MF: Matt Cavenaugh, USF
 * F: George Zabaneh, Louisville
 * F: Sean Fraser, Memphis
 * F: Flavio Monteiro, UAB

Third-Team All-Conference USA
 * GK: Jake Witkowski, Cincinnati
 * D: Stuart Langrish, Louisville
 * D: Chad Garofola, Marquette
 * D: Steve Lawrence, Marquette
 * MF: Johan Cedergren, Cincinnati
 * MF: Joe Ahearn, DePaul
 * MF: Joe Hammes, Saint Louis
 * MF: Brian Waltrip, USF
 * F: Stephen Miller, Charlotte
 * F: Chris Greer, DePaul
 * F: Vedad Alagic, Saint Louis

1998
First-Team All-Conference USA
 * GK: Jim Welch, Marquette
 * D: C.J. Robinson, Charlotte
 * D: Kevin Kalish, Saint Louis
 * D: Ken Costello, USF
 * MF: Christian Lund, Charlotte
 * MF: Jeff DiMaria, Saint Louis
 * MF: Brian Alvero, USF
 * MF: Jeff Houser, USF
 * F: Jon Mabee, Charlotte
 * F: Kevin Alvero, USF
 * F: Brian Waltrip, USF

Second-Team All-Conference USA
 * GK: Jake Witkowski, Cincinnati
 * D: Andrew Kean, Cincinnati
 * D: Brad Ruzzo, Cincinnati
 * D: Wes Elias, USF
 * MF: Pablo Pinzon, Charlotte
 * MF: Jason Mims, Saint Louis
 * MF: Mike Moriarty, Saint Louis
 * MF: Rumbani Munthali, UAB
 * F: David Hughes, Charlotte
 * F: Brian Benton, Saint Louis
 * F: Peter Byaruhanga, UAB

Third-Team All-Conference USA
 * GK: Skip Miller, USF
 * D: Jeremiah Bass, Marquette
 * D: Chris Howle, UAB
 * D: Thor-Arne Loveland, USF
 * MF: Jamath Shoffner, Charlotte
 * MF: Shawn Faria, Louisville
 * MF: Stuart Langrish, Louisville
 * MF: Matt Briggs, Memphis
 * F: Myron Vaughn, Cincinnati
 * F: Steven Brooks, Memphis
 * F: Erik Kuster, UAB

1997
First-Team All-Conference USA
 * GK: Jim Welch, Marquette
 * D: Ben Parry, Charlotte
 * D: Max Stoka, Marquette
 * D: Kevin Kalish, Saint Louis
 * MF: Matthys Barker, Charlotte
 * MF: Kevin Quigley, Saint Louis
 * MF: Joe Mattacchione, UAB
 * MF: Brian Waltrip, USF
 * F: David Hughes, Charlotte
 * F: Rogerio Lima, Memphis
 * F: Jeff Cunningham, USF

Second-Team All-Conference USA
 * GK: Casey Klipfel, Saint Louis
 * D: Jim Kunevicius, Charlotte
 * D: Mike Moriarty, Saint Louis
 * D: Rumbani Munthali, UAB
 * MF: Christian Lund, Charlotte
 * MF: Donny Mark, Marquette
 * MF: Brian Corcoran, UAB
 * MF: Darick Metrius, USF
 * F: Drew Watzka, Marquette
 * F: Emmanuel Eloundou, UAB
 * F: Jeff Houser, USF

Third-Team All-Conference USA
 * GK: Mike Mobley, Cincinnati
 * D: Jeremiah Bass, Marquette
 * D: Ken Costello, Saint Louis
 * D: Tim Tedoni, Saint Louis
 * MF: Shawn Faria, Louisville
 * MF: Stuart Langrish, Louisville
 * MF: Ramon Aguillon, Memphis
 * MF: Tony Carpenter, USF
 * F: Brian Benton, Saint Louis
 * F: Joe DiNardo, UAB
 * F: Erik Kuster, UAB

1996
First-Team All-Conference USA
 * GK: Jon Busch, Charlotte
 * D: Joe Mattacchione, UAB
 * MF: Matthys Barker, Charlotte
 * MF: Fergal Forde, Memphis
 * F: Drew Watzka, Marquette
 * F: Rogerio Lima, Memphis
 * F: Mark Filla, Saint Louis
 * F: Emmanuel Eloundou, UAB
 * F: Jeff Cunningham, USF
 * F: Todd Denault, USF

Second-Team All-Conference USA
 * D: Jim Kunevicius, Charlotte
 * D: Scott Ziemba, Marquette
 * MF: Christian Lund, Charlotte
 * MF: Tim Hamm, Cincinnati
 * MF: Antonio Azcona, Louisville
 * MF: Billy Solberg, Marquette
 * MF: Kevin Quigley, Saint Louis
 * MF/F: Tim Leonard, Saint Louis
 * F: Kevin Berry, Marquette
 * F: Erik Kuster, UAB
 * F: Thomas Holmen, USF

Third-Team All-Conference USA
 * GK: Mike Mobley, Cincinnati
 * GK: Loukas Papaconstantinou, UAB
 * D: Kevin Bateman, DePaul
 * D: Ken Costello, Saint Louis
 * D: Mike Moriarty, Saint Louis
 * D: Esa Tabi, UAB
 * D: Danny Ziannis, UAB
 * MF/D: Michael Kim, Louisville
 * MF: Matt Bradner, Charlotte
 * F: Stephen Pugliese, Charlotte
 * F: Dan Stokes, DePaul

1995
First-Team All-Conference USA
 * GK: Jon Busch, Charlotte
 * GK: Loukas Papaconstantinou, UAB
 * D: Mike Franks, Charlotte
 * MF: Billy Solberg, Marquette
 * MF: Eric Cherveny, Saint Louis
 * MF: Matt McKeon, Saint Louis
 * F: Mac Cozier, Charlotte
 * F: Cedric Thompson, DePaul
 * F: Jacob Thomas, Saint Louis
 * F: William Guimmarra, UAB
 * F: Jeff Cunningham, USF

Second-Team All-Conference USA
 * D: Joe Mattacchione, UAB
 * D: Danny Ziannis, UAB
 * MF: Billy Hamilton, Cincinnati
 * MF: Antonio Azcona, Louisville
 * MF: Fergal Forde, Memphis
 * MF: Kevin Quigley, Saint Louis
 * MF: Brian Corcoran, UAB
 * MF: Mike Mekelburg, USF
 * MF/F: Cory Butler, Marquette
 * F: Bernard Licari, Memphis
 * F: Mats Hagedorn, UAB

Honorable Mention All-Conference USA
 * GK: Jim Welch, Marquette
 * D: Grady Farmer, Charlotte
 * D: James LaBar, Cincinnati
 * D: Scott Ziemba, Marquette
 * D: Mike Moriarty, Saint Louis
 * D: Pat Moriarty, Saint Louis
 * D: Todd Denault, USF
 * D: Trip Ellis, USF
 * MF/D: Michael Kim, Louisville
 * MF: Patric Gross, Marquette
 * F: Thomas Holmen, USF