New York Mutuals all-time roster

The New York Mutuals baseball club, established 1859, played five seasons in the National Association, 1871–1875, and one in the National League, 1876. Here is a list of all their players in regular season games beginning 1871.

† Bold names identify members of the National Baseball Hall of Fame.

A

 * Doug Allison

B

 * Billy Barnie
 * George Bechtel
 * Steve Bellán
 * Eddie Booth
 * Bill Boyd
 * Jack Burdock

C

 * Tom Carey
 * Bill Craver
 * Candy Cummings†

E

 * Dave Eggler

F

 * George Fair
 * Bob Ferguson
 * Frank Fleet
 * Davy Force
 * Chick Fulmer

G

 * Count Gedney
 * Billy Geer
 * Joe Gerhardt

H

 * Jimmy Hallinan
 * John Hatfield
 * John Hayes
 * George Heubel
 * Nat Hicks
 * Dick Higham
 * Jim Holdsworth

L

 * Terry Larkin

M

 * John Maloney
 * Phonney Martin
 * Bobby Mathews
 * Pat McGee
 * John McGuinness
 * John McMullin
 * Al Metcalf
 * Charlie Mills

N

 * Candy Nelson
 * Al Nichols

P

 * Tom Patterson
 * Dickey Pearce
 * Nealy Phelps

R

 * Jack Remsen

S

 * George Seward
 * Jim Shanley
 * Orator Shaffer
 * Charlie Smith
 * Joe Start

T

 * Fred Treacey
 * Pete Treacey

V

 * Bob Valentine

W

 * Billy West
 * Rynie Wolters