Talk:Íslendingabók (genealogical database)

Removal of material critical of Íslendingabók
Over the past few months, User:Thordurkristjans has made a series of edits to this article. While many might be seen as helpful streamlining and fact-checking, overall the edits have involved removing most of the criticisms of Íslendingabók, despite the descriptions of the criticisms consistently citing scholarly publications. I'm concerned that this has reduced the balance of the article's coverage of the subject, and wonder if we might be seeing a case of Conflict of interest. I wonder if Thordurkristjans would like to comment before I start putting some of the criticism back in? Thanks! Alarichall (talk) 09:08, 14 October 2017 (UTC)


 * PS I note that all this user's edits so far are about Íslendingabók or the company that made it: Special:Contributions/ThordurkristjansAlarichall (talk) 11:22, 15 October 2017 (UTC)