Talk:2013 Jhankar Saikia mob lynching

Feedback from New Page Review process
I left the following feedback for the creator/future reviewers while reviewing this article: Thanks for the article!.

&maltese; SunDawn &maltese;    (contact)   02:01, 7 June 2022 (UTC)


 * @SunDawn Where I can see the feedback? Link please. - Signed by NeverTry4Me Talk 02:38, 7 June 2022 (UTC)
 * @SunDawn Can I expand it or this is just enough? - Signed by NeverTry4Me Talk 02:43, 7 June 2022 (UTC)
 * I think this is enough. Thanks for creating the article!  &maltese; SunDawn &maltese;     (contact)   03:56, 7 June 2022 (UTC)
 * @SunDawn my pleasure, Such incidents should be in the Wiki as per my opinion. - Signed by NeverTry4Me Talk 12:05, 7 June 2022 (UTC)

Inconsistent title
I notice that the title of this article is inconsistent with other articles about lynchings that resulted in the violent death of a single person. I recently moved an article originally called 2019 Deben Dutta mob lynching to Lynching of Deben Dutta, also started by user NeverTry4Me. When naming an article about the lynching of a single person the naming conventions for violence and deaths should take precedence over the naming conventions for events. Because the victim is named in the title, this article should be called "Lynching of Jhankar Saikia". The alternative name, treating this as an event and which is mentioned in sources, would be the "2013 Assam mob lynching". However, a mob or crowd is the usually feature of a "Lynching", so mentioning in the title that it was a "mob lynching" seems superfluous to me. Also, in other articles about "mob lynchings" a group of people are usually lynched, so naming all the victims in the title is less practical. Adding "2013" to the title is also only needed if there are multiple events that would otherwise have the same title. Since Jhankar Saikia died as a result of this event, the chance of multiple events of the same name, but in different years, would seem very remote, so mentioning the year in the title is unnecessary. Lastly, given the court found the case proved under section 302 of the IPC, which is for murder, and included convictions of life imprisonment at sentencing, the generic title for Murder of articles, could also be used. However, "Lynching of Jhankar Saikia" is more precise and unambiguous. - Cameron Dewe (talk) 07:12, 11 June 2022 (UTC)


 * @Cameron Dewe I suggest "Jhankar Saikia mob lynching" as the title. Hope you have no objection. - Signed by NeverTry4Me  Talk 07:38, 11 June 2022 (UTC)


 * That title would be inconsistent with the Lynching of Deben Dutta and numerous other Lynching of articles. Also, the sources are inconsistent about using a single natural commonly recognizable name, some omit the word "mob", while others call this a "Murder", some use the victim's name, while other sources use "Assam". I am curious why you think "Jhankar Saikia mob lynching" is a better name than the "Lynching of Jhankar Saikia" in terms of the various Wikipedia guidelines? Can you point to any recommendation that supports the title you suggest? - Cameron Dewe (talk) 09:28, 11 June 2022 (UTC)
 * I still vote for "Jhankar Saikia mob lynching" as the title. - Signed by NeverTry4Me Talk 09:59, 11 June 2022 (UTC)
 * I do note that Wikipedia is not a democracy nor is it a bureaucracy. Decisions are made by consensus, so to achieve that I need to understand why you prefer "Jhankar Saikia mob lynching" as an article title. While I have explained why I think "Lynching of Jhankar Saikia" is a more suitable title, you do need to put forward a rational argument why the title you preferred would be better. Please remember, it is not just me you need to persuade but it is the whole Wikipedia community of editors. Simply saying you vote for a particular name is not enough, you need to provide reasons that will convince the consensus of editors to favour your preferred title. - Cameron Dewe (talk) 10:35, 11 June 2022 (UTC)
 * @Cameron Dewe for example 2015 Dadri lynching page, if we remove the year from first then it will become "Dadri lynching". Thus, I opined for "Jhankar Saikia mob lynching" or you remove "mob" from the title. Your suggested one, i.e. "Lynching of Jhankar Saikia" is also a nice one. - Signed by NeverTry4Me Talk 22:32, 11 June 2022 (UTC)