Talk:A Moment of War

UHEP? OACP?
Chapter 4:

''...we volunteers ... marched around Albacete shouting new-learned slogans in pigeon Spanish: 'Ooachaypay! No pasaran! Muera las Facistas! Salud!'''

Ooachaypay? What would that be? Humphrey Jungle (talk) 22:40, 26 June 2008 (UTC)


 * Ah, its the UHP: see Behind the Spanish barricades: reports from the Spanish Civil War, John Langdon-Davies, 1937 and Confederación Nacional del Trabajo. Humphrey Jungle (talk) 18:59, 10 January 2010 (UTC)

Dubious activities
Lee also describes his work on a little squad of soldiers whose job, apparently, was to rough up those who were unsympathetic to the Republican cause. He portrays himself as not very focussed on this task, and it's evident from his tone that he didn't particularly enjoy it, but at the same time, he deflects the possibly very nasty implications of the job by treating it somewhat comically, as if he were a mere naif. This, for me, has always been the most puzzling part of the book. How could he possibly not have known that such squads were (potentially, if not actually) murder gangs? To me, this was always why it took him so long to write the book, a sense of shame at having participated in victimizing people just because some political boss told him to go an do it. The diaries were in his possession for a long time, and yet he only began to write after they were stolen; why? Because then there is only the one account of an (admitedly, that is, by himself) fallible witness, and no other account to contradict it.

I agree with the summary of the book at the end of the article, that in general the book paints a fair portrait of his time in Spain. But that nasty little job and its implications sticks in my mind, and I wonder if there is any way to check on what actually happened.Theonemacduff (talk) 06:43, 27 September 2009 (UTC)