Talk:Admittedly Incomplete Demos

Possiblity of Recreation
While the issue that likely ultimately led to this page's deletion was its overall lack of importance, it's still important to note the sourcing issue and to compare the page to Complete Demos.

Complete Demos only has a source to one of its facts yet has been up for a while, and it categorically serves little more purpose than the page for Admittedly Incomplete Demos ever did. It might be viable to create a new page for Admittedly Incomplete Demos if it were to expand upon the overall background/significance of the album (namely the Just a Friend cover), and received a revamp to its citations.

In the spirit of elevating Admittedly Incomplete Demos to a comparable level of importance as Complete Demos, I've roughly drafted an article for it on User:Peenwald/sandbox. I've taken as much inspiration from the Complete Demos Wikipedia page as possible while gathering a number of sources, and avoiding hiddeninthesand.com after the discourse surrounding the page's deletion. I'd love to hear any discussion about the return of the page if possible! That sandbox page was only made very recently (and I'm quite unfamiliar with editing Wikipedia sadly), but any traction that could be gained on the discourse for this would be appreciated.

Or maybe it would be in the right to delete the Complete Demos page as well for similar reasons? Most of its content and trivia could be merged with Tally Hall anyways so I'd just be happy with consistency.

Peenwald (talk) 19:49, 11 June 2022 (UTC)