Talk:Ahmad Surkati

[Untitled]
"Ahmad Surkati was silent and could not reply with any arguments when his opinion was contested by Abdullah bin Muhammad Sadaqah Dahlan, who later replaced his position, with the same strong arguments based on al-Quran and sound sunnah. A rebuttal was even written by Dahlan Abdullah Abdullah al-Aqib, one of Surkati's student, with the title of al-Khitab Fashl fi Ta'yid Surah. In addition to Dahlan's writing, there are other writings discussing kafa'ah in Alawi society, one of them is al-Burhan al-Nuroni fi Dahdh Muftaroyat al-Sinari al-Sudani by Habib Alwi bin Husein Mudaihij. Further arguments written by Surkati and supporters eroded out by the book published in 1926 entitled al-Qaul al-Fashl fima li Bani Hasyim wa Quraish wa al-Arab min al-Fadhl written by Mufti of Johor Alwi bin Thahir al-Haddad."

Any evidence for the above? Otherwise I would propose to remove it. — Preceding unsigned comment added by Khairulash (talk • contribs) 05:19, 18 April 2017 (UTC)