Talk:Andrew Rudnick

Notability
(pasted in from my talk page )

Hi It's great that you are checking the notability of topics and reviewing new pages but I do think you should take a closer look at the notability of https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Andrew_Rudnick. There are actually several articles that discuss the topic in detail, not just mention it in passing. Here's one

https://axcessnews.com/entertainment/breaking-entertainment/why-festive-entrepreneur-andrew-rudnick-chose-to-enter-the-retail-beauty-industry_8199/

Here's another

https://blogs.timesofisrael.com/the-man-behind-the-matzoball-christmas-eve-singles-parties/

and another

https://www.tabletmag.com/jewish-life-and-religion/187629/matzo-ball-singles

there's also this source

https://axcessnews.com/entertainment/breaking-entertainment/why-festive-entrepreneur-andrew-rudnick-chose-to-enter-the-retail-beauty-industry_8199/

I know your edit was in good faith but I think you may have made a mistake on this occasion.

Best regards, Purple flowers by defaultt@lk 12:40, 2 February 2019 (UTC)


 * Hi . Thanks for that.  I am going to move this to the Talk Page of the article in question Andrew Rudnick which is the best place to discuss and ensure that a record is kept of the facts covered. Britishfinance (talk) 13:40, 2 February 2019 (UTC)


 * Hi (again) . The key in notability (or WP:GNG) for a WP:BLP is that there must be several (ideally 5), independent (e.g. not publicity about the event, or from his companies), and significant sources (per WP:RS, major outlets) on the subject in question.  In addition, articles which are really about the event that Andrew has organized can be challenged, and a case made that his BLP be absorbed into the WP article on the event (which is considered to have met WP:NEVENT).  The above references are lower-grade (axcessnews.com), really about the event (timesofisrael), or lower-grade and about the event (tablemag.com).  What you need is higher grade (e.g. major newspapers), discussing the subject due to his notability.  Without that, this article could be challenged as a WP:AFD on notability failure.  Hope that helps. Britishfinance (talk) 13:50, 2 February 2019 (UTC)