Talk:Assisting Military Officer (ARB)

Untitled
A misleading tag was applied to this article. That tag, when instantiated, directs readers to the detailed explanation on the talk page.

The no doubt well meaning contributor who applied this tag neglected to complete the process by leaving an explanation of what triggered their concern the article was misleading.

I will remove that tag after a reasonable period of time, if no explanation is supplied. Geo Swan (talk) 17:50, 5 December 2009 (UTC)


 * Thank's for asking me about my rational for adding the misleading tag. Many of the reasons are already explained by a brief look at the article and a look at the other tags and page history. Here is the summary.


 * The article is solely based on two primary sources closely affiliated with the subject.


 * No references that appear in reliable third-party publications.


 * Article is part of the highly controversial topic Guantanamo.


 * Article has been written by just one author.


 * The articles solely author has show a strong POV.


 * NPOV needs to be checked as it is solely base on United States government documents.


 * Some information in the article are not verified by the sources.

It is the large sum and combination of all these factors that make me believe that the tag is justified. No objection for removal after a substantial amount of these problems have been fixed. IQinn (talk) 09:02, 6 December 2009 (UTC)