Talk:Aubrey Logan

Awards table
Seems like the cleanest way to input facts without possibility of COI prose. Reference #3 is already in the article. Thank you! ESparky (talk) 01:40, 22 February 2018 (UTC)

Awards

 * 2006
 * Full scholarship
 * Berklee College of Music
 * Won
 * Major: Trombone performance (2010)
 * 2009
 * Audience's Choice Award
 * Montreux Jazz Festival
 * Won
 * 2009
 * Jury’s First Place
 * Montreux Jazz Festival
 * Won
 * 2009
 * Golden Ticket
 * American Idol
 * Won
 * Advance to Hollywood round.
 * 2017
 * Jazz Division
 * USA Songwriting Competition
 * Won
 * For "Pity Party" with Lisa Cole Bass (First place in Jazz and third place in overall competition)
 * Golden Ticket
 * American Idol
 * Won
 * Advance to Hollywood round.
 * 2017
 * Jazz Division
 * USA Songwriting Competition
 * Won
 * For "Pity Party" with Lisa Cole Bass (First place in Jazz and third place in overall competition)
 * Won
 * For "Pity Party" with Lisa Cole Bass (First place in Jazz and third place in overall competition)

Reply 22-FEB-2018
per WP:N and WP:SPIP
 * Not sure what you consider SPIP, the tour date mentioned in the NPR affiliate's feature interview was Tuesday night. It is my understanding that the Notability guidelines do not apply to the contents of the article WP:NNC. The awards go to WP:NTEMP. Yes, I know the artist, therefore I will only suggest prose, but the only money changing hands is me buying her music. Thank you. ESparky (talk) 18:53, 22 February 2018 (UTC)


 * My error, I selected WP:N when I meant to select WP:NPOV (my response script shortens this as Np. I mistyped and placed only N). Merely being true, or even verifiable, does not automatically make something suitable for inclusion in Wikipedia. Articles should not become a complete exposition of all possible details, but rather, a  of accepted knowledge regarding their subjects. Verifiable and sourced statements like the ones from your request are treated with appropriate weight. Items such as Berklee's acceptance of a scholarhip application or Ms. Logan's 3rd place in a competition organized in part by Berklee, appear as weighted towards Berklee and its interests more so than an independent reference on these matters would. If there are WP:RS of a third party nature which speak to these awards, please advise.       Spintendo       19:32, 22 February 2018 (UTC)


 * In many cases, an incomplete exposition of details causes problems on Wikipedia.


 * Upon further examination I'm finding that the songwriter's award is a win in two categories, first place in Jazz and third place overall, which is why I'm finding conflicting references. The reason I included the reprinted press release from NBC29 was for WP:NPOV reasons to disclose the perceived ambiguity and to properly credit the co-writer's name (I.e., she didn't write it alone and not disclosing would appear NPOV). I did not notice that Berklee was last on the list of sponsors, I don't think there is a conspiracy, I haven't seen Berklee mention the win anywhere -- a site search yields nothing. :)


 * Possible References:
 * The primary source, to disambiguate that the song won two awards.
 * The NPR affiliate podcast interview intro (prose written by the author)
 * A standard staff story I just found by Music Connection.
 * The NBC29 reprint to document the co-writer credit.


 * I consider a full scholarship in music, for a musician, a notable award (scholarships are awarded). Different case if the scholarship was for math. I believe that the industry specific scholarship goes to WP:SUSTAINED.


 * I'm going to update the awards table with the Music Connection and primary reference. ESparky (talk) 21:53, 22 February 2018 (UTC)

Singles

 * "U Can't Touch This" MC Hammer jazz cover (2017)

There are tour dates at the bottom of the Billboard feature, but they are from last summer. ESparky (talk) 18:38, 22 February 2018 (UTC)

Reply
Clarification required Per WP:MINDREADER — unable to discern. Please advise on placement. Regards,      Spintendo       19:53, 22 February 2018 (UTC)


 * There is a singles section in the Discography. One of the titles did not get English press so should probably be removed. Section should probably read like this.

Singles

 * "Give It Away", Scott Bradlee's Postmodern Jukebox, feat. Aubrey Logan (2015)
 * "My Heart Will Go On", Scott Bradlee's Postmodern Jukebox, feat. Aubrey Logan (2016)
 * "U Can't Touch This", MC Hammer jazz cover (2017)


 * Thanks ESparky (talk) 23:15, 22 February 2018 (UTC)