Talk:Banu Asad

Bani Asad
What empire did he take over 2601:6C1:501:580:21AA:9CE0:2416:4B46 (talk) 19:09, 31 August 2023 (UTC)

The nonexistent Conflict with Muhammad.
the part of the page talking about "conflict with Muhammad" is misleading by promoting the act of one tribe member as the political position of the whole tribe. tulayha Al-asadi have left Islam and started his own religion which no one from bani Asadi followed, as all of his followers are from different Arabic tribes. even the prophet Muhammad have sent an army led by the Asadi Muslim leader Dirar (thirar) bin Alazwar al-asadi, which in addition to many historical evidences proves that the war between Dirar and Muhammed is a private affair for Dirar rather then being the political position of the whole tribe. I'm totally not against mentioning this war in Wikipedia (as it is already mentioned in its own page) but it should be mentioned in its own separate page only to not give a wrong image of the tribe's political affiliations during that time. The lord McHeimer (talk) 22:42, 22 February 2024 (UTC)