Talk:Baron Lisle

Item for discussion
1 Alternative Lineage.

Elizabeth Talbot - 3rd Baroness Lisle d.1487

John Grey - 4th Baron Lisle (c1481 - 1504)- Elizabeth's son by Edward Grey.

Elizabeth Grey - 5th Baroness Lisle (c1480 - 1525) - sister to John Grey - married Edmund Dudley (c1462 - 17 Aug 1510)

1st child of Edmund & Elizabeth was John Dudley (c1501 - 22 Aug 1553) who was 1st Duke of Northumberland

John Dudley married Jane Guildford

children :-

John Dudley (c1527 - 21 Oct 1554) - 2nd Earl of Warwick

Ambrose Dudley (c1528 - 21 Feb 1590 - 3rd Earl of Warwick, 1st Baron Lisle


 * General comment from general knowledge: women did not sit in parliament, their husband's did the job on their behalf - so scrub 3rd baroness Lisle and 5th baroness Lisle. Don't know why the others are numbered as they are, possibly just one of those quirky little mediaeval things! Eddaido (talk) 11:20, 10 September 2011 (UTC)


 * True they didn't sit in parliament but if the husband alread had a more senior title then their "Title" inherited as the only remaining heir from their father still incremented the count before passing to a Junior male from the next Generation.


 * Clearly The Earl of Warwick is a more Senior Title so ehen the Barony of Lisle was Recreated in 1551 it went to the 2nd son Ambrose.


 * Please indent your replies. You should sign your comments. I think you are making the mistake of generalizing from some special cases - suggest more and closer reading of that subject. Eddaido (talk) 11:46, 10 September 2011 (UTC)
 * I don't have an account so signing my replies would only give an IP Address which would be invalid as soon as my router was rebooted. I'm not Generalising or looking at special cases, i'm following actual documented lines of succession that have given me these guidelines to look for.

86.151.183.144 (talk) 13:32, 10 September 2011 (UTC)

Proposal
The English Barons Lisle and the Irish Barons Lisle were totally unrelated, so maybe the article should be split - compare Earl of Ormond (Scotland) and Earl of Ormond (Ireland), Earl of Carrick and Earl of Carrick (Ireland), Earl of Ross and Gore Baronets. It would make sense to have the English Barons Lisle on the same page as the Viscounts Lisle as they frequently overlapped, so how about moving the English Barons to Viscount Lisle and leaving the holders of the current title here? Opera hat (talk) 23:14, 19 September 2011 (UTC)

Second and Third creations
If Robert de Lisle of Rougemont (who was created Baron in 1311) was the father of Gerard de Lisle who got the Manor of Kingston from his mother Alice Fitzgerold (wife of Robert), why was a third creation needed for the grandson of this Gerard, as this grandson was a direct male line descendant of Robert? Gerard von Hebel (talk) 23:39, 28 October 2013 (UTC)


 * See Gerard Lisle, 1st Baron Lisle - "Gerard II de Lisle, 1st Baron Lisle ... was born circa 1304,[1] the son and heir of Sir Warin de Lisle, of Kingston Lisle in the parish of Sparsholt, Berkshire, Keeper of Windsor Castle, by his wife Alice le Tyeys, daughter of Henry le Tyeys, 1st Lord Tyeys. His grandfather was Gerard I de Lisle of Kingston Lisle, the younger son of Robert de Lisle of Rougemont by his wife Alice FitzGerold (granddaughter of Henry I FitzGerold (d.1173/4)), the heiress of Kingston." The Robert de Lisle of Rougemont who was married to Alice Fitzgerold was the great-grandfather of the Robert de Lisle who was summoned in 1311. There is a family tree between pages 48 and 49 of Volume 8 of the 2nd edition of the Complete Peerage which gives the following descent


 * 1. Robert (died ?1262) - husband of Alice Fitzgerold


 * 2. Robert (died 1284)


 * 3. Warin (died 1296)


 * 4. Robert, 1st Lord Lisle summoned 1311 (died 1344)


 * Alekksandr (talk) 16:52, 25 July 2021 (UTC)