Talk:Batch distillation

Edits to references and book citations
First, let me say that I think this is an extremely well researched article. I converted all of the references in the text of the article to the Wiki recommended format. In so doing, the text contained a reference to Lang et al. (1999) but the reference list did not contain that reference ... so I included a "citation needed" tag next to that text reference. Also, the reference list included a thesis by Hilmen Eva-Katrine but there was no reference in the text to that thesis ... so I moved that thesis listing to the Further Reading section.

I also converted the three book references in the Further Reading section to the Wiki preferred format and added some missing info to them (i.e., ISBN numbers). - mbeychok 04:00, 19 September 2006 (UTC)

Diagrams need work
The Diagrams need some work.

in Diagram of a Batch Rectifier there is no indication of how the set-up is charged (into the Pot/Reboiler no doubt)

in Diagram of a Batch Stripper there are two product outlets and the description is confusing if compared to the diagram. There is a rather minimal heating source through the re-boiler with the charge entering the column at ambient temperature.

in Diagram of a Middle Vessel Column there is no mention of how the set-up is charged (into the middle vessel no doubt) and the method that the products flow through the middle vessel are not indicated or described in any way, basically just through flow or some other magic. There is a rather minimal heating source through the re-boiler with the charge entering the column at ambient temperature.

Idyllic press (talk) 17:13, 27 February 2018 (UTC)