Talk:Battle of Aden (1586)

Merge with Ottoman-Portuguese conflicts (1586-1589)
Support. Does not meet WP:GNG and was already contained in target. The user who created this page has a history of dedicating articles to extremely trivial events, does not seem aware that Wikipedia allows users to take the initiative to merge pages, and does not respect consensus after the merge had been performed twice by two different users. Wareno (talk) 16:01, 4 January 2023 (UTC)
 * Support - while I do not agree that this passes GNG, it makes sense to merge a battle from 1586 between the Ottomans and the Portuguese, which is a short stub, into a short article about the conflicts between the Ottomans and the Portuguese between 1586-1589. Onel 5969  TT me 18:08, 4 January 2023 (UTC)
 * Oppose. The article clearly does meet WP:GNG, therefore merging due to notability would be inappropriate. Moreover, if we were to merge all Portuguese-Ottoman battles to the same page the resulting article would be too long (see WP:NOTMERGE), it is also quite convenient that the user only wants to merge articles that have Ottoman victory but not Portuguese victory, clearly POV pushing and WP:JDLI. Kabz15 (talk)