Talk:Battle of Bajrur

Poorly sourced edit
The content added in this edit is poorly sourced. It cites four sources. The first source is a locally published nonscholarly/non-HISTRS Punjabi source, namely Rangretian daa itihas, which is authored by Naranjan Arifi, a retired employee of the Punjab government's Revenue Department. He is not even a scholar, let alone a historian – see WP:SPS for such sources. One of the primary sources added by them is Singh Sagar, which was authored in the early 19th century by some obscure Sikh poet. The other primary source cited by them is (Shahid Bilas) which was authored in the 19th century by a poet named Seva Singh. They didn't mention the page number of their fourth source. But the description about this locally-published source shows that it is authored by a Punjabi author Harbhajan Singh Dehradun in collaboration with some "Sikh Jago Lehar" (literally, Wake Up Sikhs Movement), which seems like a local WP:RIGHTGREATWRONGS group of Sikhs.

Feel free to reinstate the content after citing WP:SCHOLARSHIP.

NitinMlk (talk) 02:21, 14 January 2024 (UTC)