Talk:Battle of Mu'tah/draft

The Battle of Mu'tah (معركة مؤتة, غزوة مؤتة) was fought in 629 CE (XX XXX X AH in the Islamic calendar), near the village of Mu'tah, located in the Jordan Valley, to the east of the Jordan River, between a force of Muslims dispatched by their prophet Muhammad and an army of the Byzantine Empire army. In historical Muslim sources, the battle is usually portrayed as a heroic feat wherein the Muslims faced off against a vastly larger Roman force. Western academic scholars however view the battle as an unsuccessful expedition aimed at conquering the Arabs living to the east of Jordan.

Background
A year after the treaty of Hudaybiyyah brought a period of peace with the Quraish and the conversion of Badhan the Sassanid governor of Yemen to Islam bringing many of the southern Arabian sheikhs and their tribes to Islam, Muhammad began to focus on the Arab tribes in the Bilad al-Sham to the North. Here he is reported to have sent envoys and missionaries to the Banu Sulaym and Dhat al Talh who were killed. Accounts vary on the specific trigger for the muslim expedition, some report it as the murder of the 15 people sent to Dhat al Talh, others report an account of the murder of a messenger by Suhrabil a Ghassanid governor of al Balqa'. headed to the governor of Basra. The expedition sent to the north was the largest muslim army raised against a non-meccan confederate force and would be the first with cronfrontation with the Byzantines who controlled the region through alliances with regional frontier.

Mobilizatition of the armies
According to most accounts Muhammad dispatched 3,000 troops to the area on Jumada I of the year 8 A.H. (629 C.E.), for a quick expedition to surprise and punish the Ghassanids. The army was led by Zayd ibn Haritha, whose deputy was Jafar ibn Abi Talib, who in case of his death was supposed to be replaced by the poet Abdullah ibn Rawahah. Muhammed ordered the Muslim army:

"Fight the disbelievers in the Name of Allah, neither breach a covenant nor entertain treachery, and under no circumstances a new-born, woman, an ageing man or a hermit should be killed; moreover neither trees should be cut down nor homes demolished. [Mukhtasar Seerat Ar-Rasool p.327]

Suhrabil, however is reported to have gained word of the expedition and prepared his forces and sent to the Byzantines for aid. Muslim historians reported that the Byzantine emperor Heraclius himself had gathered an army and arrived to camp at Moab where they met up with their arab allies, while others relate that it was rather his brother Theodorus who did this. The combined force is usally reported as either 100,000 or, according to ibn Hisham, 200,000 strong.. When the Muslim troops arrived at the area to the east of Jordan and learnt of the size of the Byzantine army, they wanted to wait and send for reinforcements from Medina. Abdullah ibn Rawaha however is reported to have taken them to task at this and inspired into the soldiers so that they immediately resumed their march upon the enemy.

The Battle
The Muslims engaged the Byzantines at their camp by the village of Musharif and then withdrew drawing them towards Mu'tah, which presented to them strategic advantages, and they fortified their position. Khalid ibn Al-Walid reported that the fighting was so intense that he used nine swords which broke in the battle. In the six days of the battle, all three Muslim leaders fell one after the other as they took command of the force: first, Zayd ibn Haritha, then Jafar ibn Abi Talib, then Abdullah ibn Rawaha. Al-Bukhari reported that there were fifty stabs in Jafar's body. After the death of the latter, the troops asked Thabit ibn Arkan to assume command; however, he declined and offered Khalid ibn al-Walid to take the lead. Al-Walid, seeing that it was meaningless to remain in Mu'tah decided to prepare a withdrawal. He countinued to engage the Byzantines in skirmishes and avoided pitched battle to gain time. He reshuffled the right and left flanks of the Muslim army and introduced forward a division from the rear in order to delude the Byzantines that fresh reinforcements had arrived. The Muslims engaged with the Bizantines in sporadic skirmishes but gradually retreating in a fully organized and well-planned withdrawal. The Byzantines did not follow the Muslims as they feared that another army would be lying in wait to ambush them in the desert, an the muslim army was safe in its retreat.

Muslim commentators on the battle have often lauded the skirmishing tactics of Khalid ibn Walid, and attributed the ferocity of the small muslim force, their gradual drawing of the Byzantine forces towards the desert and the sudden ruse and that they were drawing the Byzantine forces into the desert.

Criticism of the traditional Muslim account
Western academics find the traditional Muslim account of the events as an attempt to find excuses for a defeat, and as one which should not be taken seriously due to great exaggerations and embellishments, especially regarding the size of Byzantine army. Instead, they prefer the Byzantine chronicle written by the historian Theophanes, which is the earliest written mention of Muhammad. The actual reason for Muhammad’s expedition is thus atributed to his desire to subjugate the Arabs living to the east of Jordan. According to Theophanes, the Muslim army intended to attack the local Arabs on a feast day (the word that Theophanes used most likely indicates a pagan rather than a Christian holiday). However, the vicar Theodorus learnt about their plans and gathered a force from the garrisons of local fortresses. He fell upon the Muslims at Mu'tah and routed them; three of the Muslim leaders were killed, and only Khalid ibn al-Walid managed to escape. Muslim academic scholars rejects the Western view, and find the traditional view to be more reliable. They also see the battle as victory for Muslims since they were able to archive the target of the battle, which was sending a message that killing a Muslim diplomatic envoy will not be left without a punishment

Muslim veneration of the battle
Those muslim who fell at the battle are considered to be heroes and regarded as martyrs (shuhada). A mausoleum was later built at Mu'ta over their grave.

Aftermath
When the Muslims force arrived at Medina, they were berated for withdrawing and accussed of fleeing. Salamah ibn Hisham is reported to have avoided even going to the mosque to avoid taunts. A few weeks later however Muhammad began to mobilize a new force to head north against the provocation provided by Bani Quda‘a in al-sham under Amr ibn al `As, to recover political prestige among the bedioun tribes that may have dwindled in the Battle of Mu'tah and resulted the Dhat As-Salasil campaign.

Online References

 * Ar-Raheeq Al-Makhtum (THE SEALED NECTAR)
 * The Life of Muhammad