Talk:Camp Minsi (version 2)

Deleted
This article was re-created in an attempt to address the issues of a previous AfD. The new incarnation was an appropriate article for a notable camp, and asserted its nobility in line with other local council camp articles. The article was well-sourced and well-written and (most importantly) was significantly different than the one that was deleted in the AfD -- it was deleted under G4 ("Recreation of deleted material"), however it was not the same as the material contested in the AfD. If one feels that the issue of notability is not adequately addressed in the new article(although I feel nobility was adequately asserted) that issue can be addressed with some discussion, but deleting the article speedily per G4 with absolutely no discussion or consensus (and then locking the page) was not the appropriate action. -- Minsi (talk) 20:40, 17 April 2008 (UTC)