Talk:Canadian University Rankings

There appears to be some dispute on this page. I attempted to reconcile the viewpoints but don't have enough knowledge on this subject to know if I got it right.

Embee473 says the following:

I have no idea if that article is accurate or not. Someone posted it on the University of Windsor wikipage -- I knew it wasn't relevant there so I just made it its own article. Embee473 23:25, 27 May 2006 (UTC)

This article seems to be mostly false. The Ivy League in the States is a football league that happens to consist of really old, famous, East Coast universities. It is not a list of the top-ranked schools. Likewise, in Canada, the schools with medical programmes are not ranked above schools without. Maclean's does indeed have an influential ranking of universities, but it is discussed in Macleans. Furthermore, the separation by presence or absence of Medical School is not intended as a form of ranking, and thus does not support a classification into "Tier 1" or "Tier 2". I would propose this article be deleted, but don't know how. SammyBoy 23:44, 4 October 2006 (UTC)

This article also doesn't mention anything about Quebec universities (McGill, Concordia, UofM and Sherbrooke) which have consistently ranked in the top 10.zarkonite

It would appear that the questionabla content has been removed as I see none of what is being discussed reflected in the article.--Kdmurray