Talk:Carlo re d'Allemagna

"silent" role recorded on CD?
The role section included " Giuditta, Empress Dowager (lead role, but silent), at the time of the premiere, embodied by Margherita Durastanti". This is not possible, Durastanti was a star singer, why would an opera have a leading role played by a star singer who did not sing (or speak?) Then in the recordings section there is a singer credited with recording the role, "Roberta Invernizzi, soprano (Giuditta)'. So do they have long pauses in the recording while this singer was paid to stand there and neither sing nor speak?It is obviously ridiculous. I wonder if User:LouisAlain even reads the nonsense he puts on English WP before posting it.Smeat75 (talk) 17:12, 11 February 2019 (UTC)