Talk:Carpenter

Primary topic
I believe that the primary topic for "Carpenter" (meaning, the topic that most users are likely to be seeking when they search for the term "Carpenter") is still "a person engaged in carpentry", and thus that Carpenter should continue to redirect to Carpentry.

If in fact there is no primary topic, and thus the disambiguation page should be the first page the user sees, then the disambiguation page should be moved to Carpenter rather than having Carpenter redirect to Carpenter (disambiguation) (per the guideline at WP:DABNAME). If you think this is the case, the way to propose the change is to follow the directions at WP:Requested Moves to request that Carpenter (disambiguation) be moved to the title Carpenter. This allows users a chance to discuss the potential move and reach a consensus on the most appropriate action. Propaniac (talk) 17:32, 28 April 2010 (UTC)