Talk:Charlie Shaw (footballer, born 1885)

Almost all from Celtic Wiki
The vast majority of this article is copied in its entirety from The Celtic Wiki, a site that is not without merit in the efforts that obviously go into producing the articles. However, its content is cobbled together from various Celtic books and newspaper reports but does not cite any of these references, is an open collaborative wiki rather than a closed project by one or two persons (albeit it seems to be maintained and updated by just a few dedicated editors) so open to inaccuracy and therefore unfortunately not a reliable source, and is clearly written from a Celtic fan 'green-tinted specs' perspective to some extent, contravening WP:NPOV. The fact that the Celtic Wiki article has been lifted and pasted entirely onto Wikipedia rather than reworded also contravenes guidelines. Crowsus (talk) 07:57, 27 February 2017‎ (UTC)