Talk:Chess (musical)/GA1

GA Review
The edit link for this section can be used to add comments to the review.''

Quck fail criteria

 * 1) Has reliable sources Symbol oppose vote.svg
 * 2) Is written neutrally Symbol support vote.svg
 * 3) No valid cleanup tags Symbol oppose vote.svg
 * 4) Is relatively stable with no edit wars Symbol support vote.svg
 * 5) Not specifically concerned with a rapidly unfolding current event with a definite endpoint Symbol support vote.svg


 * Unfortunately, this article fails the quick fail criteria, therefore I am failing it. Do not be overly discouraged by this however, it can still achieve GA status with some work. The main problem here is the lack of references, which is what the cleanup tag says. Entire section of the article are unreferenced, for example:
 * Chess (musical) has no references,
 * Chess (musical) has only one reference,
 * Chess (musical) has no references
 * The entire Chess (musical) is unreferenced,
 * No references at all in the Chess (musical) section.
 * There are 11 references overall, which is really not enough for a 46 kilobyte article. Additionally, the entire text of reference 9 is "May 9, 1985", which is not a reference, it's a date.
 * Perhaps, after the article has been referenced, you should have the article Peer Reviewed. This will spot any major problems with the article, and allow you to fix them before you re-nominate it. Good luck in the future with this article. ♥ Nici ♥ Vampire ♥ Heart ♥ 18:33, 5 July 2009 (UTC)