Talk:City Lights/Archive 1

INACCURATE SCENE DESCRIPTION
"In each encounter with the blind girl, she unknowingly manages to bash the Tramp, throwing water in his face, dropping a flower pot on his head etc."

This is not accurate; the cat hit the flower pot which fell on his head, not the blind girl. The blind girl, hearing the noise, then rushed to the window to make sure it wasn't her bird cage that had fell. A better example would be of her using his underclothes to supply her yarn ball. Also, did this not happen in "each encounter" -- perhaps two or three times.

.. Also, he didn't look through the glass at her, there was no glass separating them. Also, the look on his face when he realized it was her in NO way resembled the way he checked out the naked statue in the window in the beginning of the movie, and I do not see how this is an analogy. Did the person that wrote this actually watch the movie? — Preceding unsigned comment added by 12.204.16.2 (talk) 14:41, 1 February 2013 (UTC)

B-Class Assessment
The article can be improved to B-Class after these problems are solved:
 * The lead is too short.
 * Unsourced paragraphs on both "Slapstick" and "Reception and Legacy".
 * Regarding the latter, maybe a section named "Accolades" (which I just created) could fit all the lists the film's in - also that AFI subsection, which can be converted to prose. igordebraga ≠ 04:32, 17 October 2012 (UTC)