Talk:Coaxial

Two Topics
I think that the military bit should be on this page, and the cable bit be added to a new page: Coaxial_Cable. Does anyone else agree? Lewispb 23:08, 15 December 2005 (UTC)
 * Agreed, the page should be split. The geometric definition should be under one article, with the cable part under it, and a new page be added: Coaxial_Machine_Gun.That's just my opinion.
 * Agree, they should be split - but I propose
 * Coaxial (weapon) - Since not all coaxial weapons are machine guns. The BMP-3 has a coaxial 30 mm cannon, as well as a coaxial 7.62mm machine gun.
 * Coaxial (cable)
 * Coaxial - with the mathematic meaning. Since this is the term from which the others are derived.
 * Coaxial (disambiguation) - with the disambig links.
 * Megapixie 08:14, 28 December 2005 (UTC)
 * Sounds like a good idea to me, however the details on each subject are a bit slim for three full entries. If they're split some additional information could be put in (like Megapixie's information about the BMP-3's coaxial guns).

Agreed, this article sundered into 3 parts, and then each expanded.

Also agreed with "Weapon", "mathematical definition" and "cable"


 * I agree with all points. Someone should split page Garrettcobb 01:08, 1 July 2006 (UTC)

How do you pronouce Coaxial?
Koaksial, Koakshial, or what?--Greasysteve13 15:16, 26 October 2006 (UTC)


 * The usually pronunciation in the United States (I have personally run a lot amount of cable and heard this from dozens of people - but I don't know if it constitutes 'original research' or 'anecdotal evidence') is "coh-AXE-ee-uhl, or CO-axle" (capitalization represents stressed syllable).


 * Is it worth mentioning in this discussion that a 7.62mm weapon is not specifically a "machine gun?" Such a low caliber would classify it as either an assault weapon or sub-machine gun depending on adherence to different criteria - I realize I'm picking nits, but we're shooting for encyclopedia not common usage.--Legomancer (talk) 04:18, 3 September 2008 (UTC)

Proposal for Deletion
Tagging for opinion - User:Garrettcobb, User:Lewispb, User:Megapixie Coaxial is not a well defined concept in Mathematics. Separate pages already exist for Coaxial cable, Coaxial antenna, Coaxial loudspeaker etc including Coaxal circles. The trivial notion of coaxial meaning a shared axis is explained in the Coaxial (disambiguation) page. Thus this page doesn't contribute to anything additional and doesn't deserve to exist. I therefore propose this page be deleted. Chaos1618 (talk) 09:03, 9 October 2018 (UTC)

I support this. The word is an adjective. I see also coaxial illumination (some use coaxial sensor) is not included.