Talk:Cold fusion theories


 *  FIRST ALLEGATION: 
 *  This article or section may contain unverified claims

Let us analyse if there are UNVERIFIED CLAIMS in the article Cold fusion theories

1- As said in the article:
 * However Quantum Ring Theory is not a cold fusion theory

2- A theory must be verified. However, as QRT is not a cold fusion theory, then it doesn’t need to be verified.

3- So, one can ask:  “Then what is shown in the article Cold fusion theories?”
 * The article shows the following facts: 


 * 3.1- There is not yet a successfull cold fusion theory. All they are essays.  This is a fact, and it is verified.


 * 3.2- There is a fundamental requirement that any candidate to be a cold fusion theory must satisfy.  If the theory does not satisfy it, it cannot be acceptable.  This is a fact, and it is verified.


 * 3.3- The fundamental requirement cannot be reached from the current foundations of Quantum Mechanics This is a fact, and it is verifiable.  As this item 3.3 is verified, then are also verified the next items 3.3.1 and 3.3.2:


 * 3.3.1- Therefore if a cold fusion theory is developed from the current foundations of QM, such theory has no chance to be successful.


 * 3.3.2- In consequence of 3.3.1 we realize that any candidate to be a cold fusion theory must be developed from some new foundations missing yet in Quantum Mechanics.  They must be incorporated to QM, in order to become viable a candidate to be a cold fusion theory.


 * 3.4- The cold fusion theorists do not know what are those new foundations missing in QM. But as these new foundations are indispensable for the success of a cold fusion theory, it means that there is no way to develop a successful theory by keeping the current method of theoretical research addopted by the theorists.  This is a fact, and it is 'verified.

4- The article Cold fusion theories shows that it is possible to satisfy the fundamental requirement by addopting the following theoretical steps:


 * 4.1- By considering the electron’s zitterbewegung as a helical trajectory.


 * 4.2- The article exhibits a link to the paper Anomalous Mass of the Neutron, where it a calculation proves that the fundamental requirement can be satisfied by considering the zitterbewegung hypothesis.

The items 4.1 and 4.2 are verified by reading the article Cold fusion theories.


 * Conclusions: 
 * 1- The article Cold fusion theories shows the following verified fact:  it is possible to satisfy theoretically the fundamental requirement indispensable to any cold fustion theory, by addopting the new foundations proposed in Quantum Ring Theory, which must be incorporated to Quantum Mechanics, in order to become viable the development of a successful cold fusion theory.


 * 2- Therefore it makes no sense to allege that the article Cold fusion Theories has “unverified claims” 

W.GUGLINSKI 00:50, 13 November 2007 (UTC)

....................................................................................................................


 *  SECOND ALLEGATION: 
 *  This article or section may contain original research

The article does not propose a theory on cold fusion. Therefore it cannot have an original research

W.GUGLINSKI 00:50, 13 November 2007 (UTC)

..................................................................................................................


 *  THIRD ALLEGATION: 
 * It may require cleanup to comply with Wikipedia's content policies, particularly neutral point of view. 

The article is written under a neutral point of view. If one alleges that it is not neutral, then he must explain where it is not neutral, and why it is not neutral

W.GUGLINSKI 00:50, 13 November 2007 (UTC)

....................................................................................................................

Redirect
I propose that this article be redirected to cold fusion. Handschuh-talk to me 08:40, 13 November 2007 (UTC)