Talk:Commodity/Archives/2014

Economic commodities comprise goods and services.[2]
I apologize for the weak English. We had a dispute on use of words at Marx goods, service, etc. Concerning this place in article preamble "Economic commodities comprise goods and services.   [2]   ]   .  "   Source  Karl Marx, "Outlines of the Critique of Political Economy (Rough Draft of 1857-1857)" contained in the Collected Works of Karl Marx and Frederick Engels:  Volume 28 (International Publishers:  New York, 1986) p.  80.

https://www.marxists.org/archive/marx/works/cw/ Go to the v.28 ( year of publication coincides 1986)looking page 80 is 78 - I there appear start page which include the 80 -to link [The Origin and Essence of Money] 78 Let search word "services" since the TOC "The Origin and Essence of Money" We find the following

"Money doesn't create these antitheses and contradictions; it is, rather, development of these contradictions and antitheses which creates the seemingly transcendental power of money. (To be further developed, influence of the transformation of all relations into money relations: taxes in kind into money taxes, rent in kind into money rent, military service into mercenary troops, all personal services in general into money services, of patriarchal, slave, serf and guild labor into pure wage labor. )"

Isn't present words that "Economic commodities comprise goods and services.   "   More shortly, it isn't present in a source. on extreme to a measure in this place. You where Marx writes about it couldn't on show more particularly.--84.44.203.214 (talk) 06:41, 12 January 2014 (UTC)