Talk:Controversies surrounding the Sport Club Dynamo

The reason for this article
I created this article due to POV concerns on my side regarding the article Sportvereinigung (SV) Dynamo. I have tried repeatetly to add a section about controversies to this article but found it continously deletet. Upon discussion with the person deleting the section I have taken up his hint and created a separate page, even so I think a sub section in the article would have been sufficent.EA210269 (talk) 02:55, 18 March 2008 (UTC)

Vandalism

 * The new article was heavily vandalised by the same anonymus user editing the SV Dynamo page, not unexpectedly, as it does not fit his ideology. Almost 20 years after the end of the Stasi, its (selve declared) agents obviously still try to silence people and contrary opinions! Excuse my outburst but I think this anonymus editor has been left roaming long enough! For more information on the anonymus editor of this article, see: Administrators' noticeboard/Archive133 under: SV Dynamo and multi-indef-blocked User:Kay Körner,EA210269 (talk) 23:24, 18 March 2008 (UTC)

Agreed. Vandalism of any sort must be stopped. Just because an article doesn’t fit the person’s ideologies, doesn’t mean they can change it to what pleases them.--DavidD4scnrt (talk) 10:00, 25 April 2008 (UTC)

Speedy deletion request
User:194.95.142.179 put a speedy deletion tag on this article with this rationale:

The BFC Dynamo belonged to the SVD! The Erich Mielke Story stands in the article about himself! Your reference is the "Dynamo list, which not is a Dynamo-list, but is a list with athletes which weren't Dynamo-Athletes! Lies! Lies! Lies! The GDR Sport is not these of Dynamo! Daniela Hunger, Andrea Pollack, Ilona Slupianek being SC Dynamo Berlin Members and these about it stands in these SC Dynamo... article! The next lie is, that the Dynamo was a doping center! (see:Dynamo-hall of fame) Rica Reinisch weren't a Dynamo! Dynamo's main organisation was the Ministry of Interior of the GDR: which includet Volkspolizei, East German Fire Service, Staatssicherheit, and Zoll (Border patrol) and not Grenztruppen (Border troops)! The Harald Czudaj wasn't a Dynamo-Member and Dynamo not his club!!!!! What does Jenapharm with Dynamo?! The Erich Mielke section with Dynamo exits already! Erich Mielke is linked at the SV Dynamo article with your "Stasi"!!! Your listed members of the SC Dynamo Berlin belonging to this article or standing there already! Create this case of doping to the page of the DTSB, when members are'nt belonging to the SV Dynamo! Harald Czudaj: You can insert him at the section alleged informants of the Staatssicherheit. Renate Vogel also not a member of the SV Dynamo or other Dynamo-Clubs! Dynamo can not help with it!

From what I can tell this seems to be more of an attempt to discuss content than a deletion rationale, so I have copied it here. Phil Bridger (talk) 11:31, 25 March 2008 (UTC)


 * The article has been, unsuccessfully, nominated for speedy deletion now four times, from three different IP addresses, which are all sockpuppets of the same multi-indef blocked user:

EA210269 (talk) 01:33, 24 April 2008 (UTC)
 * User:141.30.133.80
 * User:194.95.142.179 (2 times)
 * User:212.201.54.112

Merger and redirect
The page was merged with the SV Dynamo article, according with the result of the discussion on this articles talk page. In turn, this page was made a redirect. EA210269 (talk) 07:06, 21 June 2008 (UTC)