Talk:Criticisms of Jacques Lacan

Regarding merger request
It was previously agreed on the Lacan talk page that this should be split. I am accordingly removing the merger tag. Buffyg 7 July 2005 08:37 (UTC)

Regarding "The case of Chomsky"
This is not an encyclopaedic article about Chomsky's criticism of Lacan, and it utilizes POV in several instances. In all frankness, it is more of a response to Chomsky than a summary of his critique. I do not think this should be included in this article in its current form.


 * I agree. I would also submit that the "conclusion" is heavily POV. According to my POV, a misguided POV at that. --s


 * I would also like to state my agreement with the original posting, and with s' addition. Furthermore, it seems that the conclusion is at least partyly unrelated to the encyclopedia topic being dicussed

In agreement with the above statements I have just removed "The case of Chomsky", which I thought was a nice essay, but besides the point for Wikipedia. I have summarized its main points and included in them in the article, which I also structured somewhat. I also added a "see also" section. bastel 19:36, 5 August 2005 (UTC) This done - how do people feel about removing the NPOV tag?bastel 19:39, 5 August 2005 (UTC)

Done, and removed. Also, minor tidy to syntax and spelling in some parts. --Haemo