Talk:Dalata Hotel Group

"Notable hotels" section
Hi. I have some concerns about the newly added "notable hotels" section. Most of them (in all honesty) coloured by the previous concerns raised about the notability of the subject here and of its constituent hotels (see for example the RfD discussion and NN discussion above). And also perhaps by the PROMO/COI concerns raised over time (see for example the ANI some time ago). Without raking over those old coals however, I will simply highlight my current concerns as follows: Unless we have a clear intent for the table, and established criteria for inclusion, I'm not sure we should have such a table myself. Guliolopez (talk) 15:10, 13 February 2020 (UTC)
 * I don't understand the purpose of the "notable hotels" section. How, for example, does it differ from the "hotels" section which immediately precedes it? Other than existing as a "tabular" version of it? How does that sit with the WP:USEPROSE guideline?
 * I don't understand the inclusion criteria of the "notable hotels" section. What is our list criteria or our notability criteria? The list members don't objectively meet this project's notability criteria (in that there are no articles for many and so WP:CSC doesn't apply). Which means we may be leaving it to an editor's own subjective criteria. How does that sit with the WP:LISTCRITERIA guideline?


 * Well. In the 10 minutes it took me to write this mini-essay, it seems the section has been removed. And hence this is all largely moot. But, if the editor proposes to re-add the table, it might be worth making sure the inclusion/notability criteria is established. Before doing so. Guliolopez (talk) 15:18, 13 February 2020 (UTC)