Talk:Don't Let Me Be the Last to Know/GA1

GA Review
The edit link for this section can be used to add comments to the review.''

Reviewer: Novice7  |  Talk  13:12, 19 December 2010 (UTC)

Good, but could use some work.


 * Quick fail criteria
 * 2 DAB link, and a Dead link

Lead

 * The lead too short, try expanding.
 * The song was written by Robert Lange, Shania Twain, and Keith Scott. It was also produced by Lange. — try merging these sentences.
 * peaking at number twelve in the Bubbling Under — it is Billboard Bubbling Under Hot 100. Also, number twelve "on" the.
 * As I mentioned earlier, the lead is too short. Add details of music video, chart, critical reception...

Background and composition

 * Merge first two sentences.
 * The MTV source does not say anything about "Lange Chateau in La Tour-de-Peilz".
 * Link key, time signature, common time, tempo.
 * In the body you mention "musicnotes.com", but in reference you mention it as Musicnotes. Be consistent.

Reception

 * Source needed for many sentences.
 * What do you mean by main Billboard chart? Also, italicize "Billboard".
 * "Don't Let Me Be the Last to Know was released in strict limited edition in Australia." — strict? What does that imply?
 * Again, source needed.
 * Also, you have not mentioned anything about critical reception.

Music video

 * The source to first sentence is a fansite. Not reliable.
 * Reference should go after comma or a period.
 * "premiered on MTV's TRL on ...", not "in".
 * Is Metrolyrics a reliable source?

Track listing

 * Unsourced

Charts

 * Canada, German, US Bubbling, and Mainstream are sourced by Fansite and forum. Not reliable at all.

Credits

 * Good

Media

 * Ogg file is good.