Talk:Dresden/GA1

Failed GA
As of, the article during my review, I failed this article for Good Article status. Per WP:WIAGA, When all of those issues are resolved, this article can be renominated back. As always, if you feel disagree with my reviews, you may ask for re-reviews. &mdash; Indon ( reply ) &mdash; 15:02, 2 January 2007 (UTC)
 * 1) The article is undercited. There are a lot of unsourced sections.
 * 2) There is a cleanup template since 1 December 2006.
 * 3) Too many unnecessary external links, per WP:EL.
 * 4) Too many images; they are cluttering the article. Some images do not relate with the current paragraph and its captions are not well informative. I didn't look all of those images, but found Image:Dresd 4.jpg has no fair use rationale and Image:Dresdenschool.jpg has an obsolete license tag.


 * Indon might have also pointed out that the article needs some drastic copy-editing and there are some factual errors and elisions. Eusebeus 15:03, 4 January 2007 (UTC)