Talk:Duluth Pack

Article is capitalized, shouldn't it direct to a proper noun?
I'm not familiar with the purpose of duplicate articles with varying capitalization. But if the redirect article like this is capitalized, shouldn't it redirect to something that is capitalized, like the brand name/proper noun Duluth Pack? i.e. "it leads to a title that is associated in some way with the conventional capitalisation of this redirect title." Thanks for the guidance! ↳Hyperik (talk) 02:23, 11 September 2018 (UTC)
 * I'd say that the rules don't give us a certain answer and we should just decide here. IMO the question is, what is a person who types in "Duluth Pack" most likely trying to get to? And that leads to the debate at the Duluth pack article. There the question is: Is the term duluth pack used outside of the proprietary term meaning?  And, if that answer is yes, (which I think that it is) which is the more prevalent the generic or proprietary meaning.   To me a redirect to the proprietary sort of says that they own the term, and it appears that they don't even claim to own the term. What do you think? North8000 (talk) 11:45, 11 September 2018 (UTC)
 * It's probably less and less used as a generic term since Duluth Tent & Awning became Duluth Pack. I'm from Duluth, family in Ely, and never heard anyone call a canoe pack a "Duluth pack" unless they meant a Duluth Pack pack. But that's just my experience. :) ↳Hyperik (talk) 01:33, 12 September 2018 (UTC)
 * I just did a bunch of googling. I guess we're talking about two questions rather than one:
 * Regarding packs, whether "duluth pack" is only a brand of pack, or is it also a type of pack even if not that brand.
 * Most prevalent use of the term "Duluth Pack".    So, this would include not only discussing packs, but also the Duluth Pack company and it's non-pack merchadise.
 * I think that #2 is most relevant to this redirect page. I think that the answer to #2 is that the majority of the uses of the term (including non-pack topics) relate to the specific company. I think that this makes your choice the best choice and I'm reverting it back to your choice. Sincerely, North8000 (talk) 11:37, 13 September 2018 (UTC)