Talk:Enric Prat de la Riba

Catalan or Spanish?
We have had several changes between 'Catalan', 'Spanish' and 'Spanish Catalan' to describe Prat de la Riba.

The existence of Catalonia as a nation state during his lifetime should not be a deciding issue. He was active in the politics of Catalonia, so it is accurate to describe him as a Catalan politician, irrespective of the political status of Catalonia. He was a Catalan nationalist who presumably self-identified as Catalan, so it is appropriate to use this term for him.

My view of this is influenced by the practice used in biographies of British people, which often describe them as English, Northern Irish (or Irish), Scottish or Welsh, without this being interpreted as a rejection of a British or UK identity. A distinction is made between citizenship and nationality, see Nationality of people from the United Kingdom. However, I know that the situation in Spain is different, and I am not seeking to impose a British solution.

We should aim for clarity and follow the Manual of Style. MOS:CONTEXTBIO says: This gives us discretion to say 'Catalan', 'Spanish', or some combination of these.

Another issue is whether 'Catalan' is too obscure for general readers. With more specialised articles there is less need to explain what the terms mean, and we should expect readers of this article to know what Catalan means.

Please try to reach a consensus here and not make unilateral changes to this. Verbcatcher (talk) 04:21, 16 August 2019 (UTC)