Talk:Fishery Falls

Removal of category
Hi Kerry.

I refer to your edit, with summary: The article Fishery Falls, Queensland is about the locality. The falls themselves are in the adjacent locality and do not have an article

What I did was to deliberately and explicitly create the converse of your summary.

I wanted to have the waterfall redirect page as a place holder for the waterfall and categorised so that it appeared in the relevant category for waterfalls, but knowing that it was as yet only mentioned in the (namesake) locality article sending people to that locality article.

There are a number of such redirects, some created by others and some created by me.

I would like to revert your edit back to mine.

Comment?

Regards. Aoziwe (talk) 09:09, 14 May 2018 (UTC)
 * OK, now I understand the goal, I think there is a better solution. I wrote the Fishery Falls, Queensland article last year long before I had written the Wooroonooran, Queensland article, so the two articles were not adequately in synch about telling the reader where the falls actually are. I have updated both of these articles to make it clear the falls are in the locality Wooroonooran and not in the locality of Fishery Falls, so that makes it clear that anyone interested in the waterfall ought to be looking at the Wooroonooran article. Normally when we have to disambiguate between a natural feature (the waterfall in this case) and the human settlement (the locality), we do so with Fishery Falls (Queensland) for the natural feature and Fishery Falls, Queensland for the human settlement. So I think we should create Fishery Falls (Queensland) as a redirect to Wooroonooran, Queensland (since that is where the falls should be discussed until such time as anyone writes a separate article for the falls) and that redirect should have the Category:Waterfalls of Queensland. Then with Fishery Falls, we can create it as a disambiguation page offering  Fishery Falls (Queensland) and Fishery Falls, Queensland as alternatives. We can also add a hatnote on the Fishery Falls, Queensland article to divert anyone looking for the waterfall to see Fishery Falls (Queensland). I think going that route doesn't miscategorise anything and has a straightforward path when anyone is ready to actually write the Fishery Falls (Queensland) article. Does that make sense? If so, I am happy to implement or happy to let you implement it. If not, obviously let's discuss further. Kerry (talk) 01:40, 15 May 2018 (UTC)
 * Thanks Kerry. All ✅   Aoziwe (talk) 10:44, 15 May 2018 (UTC)