Talk:Full Metal

Although Edward Elric's is often addressed as "Full Metal," his actual title is "the Full Metal Alchemist" and thus he's not necessarily the best match for the phrase "Full Metal." Redirecting to the disambiguation page is a better choice. Bbobjs 08:15, 10 August 2007 (UTC)
 * Check out this google search. This is the most known, and there already is a Full metal disambiguation. Lord Sesshomaru (talk • edits) 20:40, 2 September 2007 (UTC)
 * In that search this is number 7. After that but still in the top 21 there are a total of 6 more images related to Full Metal Panic! Also since many of those pictures are actually of Full Metal Alchemist the anime and not The Full Metal Alchemist Edward Elric you case for having it link to him instead of the disambiguation page is void. Also a google image search isn't a valid way to decide these things. I'm reverting it back.Bbobjs 21:56, 8 November 2007 (UTC)


 * it does not matter what image is in what number slot, the stats are
 * not only does it say "Also try:full metal alchemist" but
 * on page 1
 * 12 full metal alchemist
 * 6 full metal panic
 * 3 full metal jacket
 * 2 full metal yakuza
 * on page 2
 * 12 full metal alchemist
 * 4 full metal jackete
 * 2 full metal panic
 * 2 full metal airsoft guns
 * 1 full metal ninja
 * These numbers are incorrect; "Full Metal Panic!" has 5 on page two.Bbobjs 14:10, 10 November 2007 (UTC)


 * im sorry man, but Sesshomaru has ya beat....  Ancientanubis ,  talk  Editor Review 00:20, 9 November 2007 (UTC)
 * Even if you were right it would only show that this page should redirect to Fullmetal Alchemist if anything, not Edward Elric; however unless you can present a valid reason why it should redirect to either of those pages then I have no choice but to revert it. To show that the argument presented is invalid I'll cite the case of Joker. If you google image search "Joker" you end up with 17 images of Joker (comics) of 21. Extend that to pages two and it's 30/42. Searching for "Joker" on wikipedia takes you to a disambiguation page. In the case of Full Metal you end up with 24/42 being about "Fullmetal Alchemist" or "Edward Elric," 11/42 being about Full Metal Panic!, and another forth being of something else; however on wikipedia "Full Metal" takes you to "Edward Elric?" If "Joker (Comic)" has more results and still has a disambiguation page, then why does "Full Metal" redirect to "Edward Elric?" The correct answer is that it doesn't because I'm reverting it back AGAIN. Unless you can come up with a VALID REASON why it should redirect to "Edward Elric" or any other page when "Joker" doesn't redirect, DON'T CHANGE IT. Thank you. As further proof that google searches are invalid I give you bleach vs. bleach. Bbobjs 14:10, 10 November 2007 (UTC)