Talk:Giammateo Asola

Spelling
If you try to check a Google research with "Gian Matteo Asola", you will find plenty of sources for this more correct name. "Giammateo" is an English deformation, a name which has totally no existence in Italy. Second, it is also not an English name (say, Raphael begin the acceptable version of Raffaello). so, I think it'd be considered as a typo from old-fashione English sources which we would try to suppress for a modern encyclopedia like that (for people referring to it, there's the redirect, I think). Bye.

Respectable sources spelling "Gian Matteo" or similar:
 * JSTOR, by Oxford Press (if it is not reliable this!!)
 * University of Brescia
 * Celestial Sirens: Nuns and Their Music in Early Modern Milan (Oxford Monographs on Music) by Robert L. Kendrick (see on Amazon.com)
 * Italian Societ of Musicology
 * This PhD dissertation at university of North Carolina
 * This site about sacred music
 * This Spanish site
 * Another score edited in English

Further, the [German Wikipedia spells him correctly Giovanni Matteo. In fact, the interwiki was missing due to our wrong spelling here.

Of course, I omitted all Italian sites which, of course, spells him correctly.

Bye and good work. --Attilios 08:55, 23 March 2007 (UTC)


 * Oxford UP does indeed use Giovanni Matteo pretty consistently. On the other side are Grove (online site now merged w/OUP!) and Baker's, the most common music references in the US.   Donald Fouse's Grove bibliography lists F. Caffi: Della vita e delle opere di Giammateo Asola (Padua, 1862), so I dont understand the claim that Giammateo is an English corruption... Sparafucil (talk) 05:38, 16 February 2010 (UTC)