Talk:Gil Rugai Case

Title of this article
The criteria for Wikipedia article titles includes Recognizability, Naturalness, Precision, Concision and Consistency. Usually this is a common name that appears in numerous sources. However, the title of this article appears to have been lifted directly from only one of the cited sources, that describes its list of crimes as something like "Remembering 22 crimes that shocked Brazil", and often uses a Murder of ... convention to describe the notable crimes on its list, but doesn't do so for this crime. Another cited source for this article ranks the murders of Luiz Carlos Rugai and Alessandra de Fátima Troitino as one of the 30 crimes that shook Brasil and refers to the same crime in a different way. There appears to be no consistency with naming this double murder among the various citations and little or no formal research behind the purported rankings apart from some reporter interviewing their keyboard and coming up with a list of sensational crimes to write about. Wikipedia does not usually write a biography about non-notable people who are a perpetrator of a single criminal event, just as it does not write biographies of victims of crime, unless they are notable for other reasons. To be consistent with other articles about murders this article should probably be named for the Murders of Luiz Carlos Rugai and Alessandra de Fátima Troitino, or else be a biography of Gil Rugai. - Cameron Dewe (talk) 04:45, 13 May 2023 (UTC)