Talk:Guðrøðr Magnússon/GA1

GA Review
The edit link for this section can be used to add comments to the review.''

Reviewer: J Milburn (talk · contribs) 15:44, 18 September 2016 (UTC)

Very interesting; happy to take a look. Josh Milburn (talk) 15:44, 18 September 2016 (UTC)


 * "massive" strikes me as a little informal.
 * I've switched it with "retaliatory".--Brianann MacAmhlaidh (talk) 01:56, 20 September 2016 (UTC)


 * "and became the last ruling king of the Crovan dynasty" This is a little odd; the fact he was the last wasn't immediately apparent upon his death, presumably; you could try "to succeed him; he proved to be the last ruling king of the Crovan dynasty".
 * I tweaked you wording to "and proved to be...".--Brianann MacAmhlaidh (talk) 01:56, 20 September 2016 (UTC)


 * "If Magnús' own demise did not signify the end of an independent kingdom in the Isles, the events of the following year certainly did" I've no doubt that this is right, but it strikes me as a little judgemental to be presented in Wikipedia's neutral voice.
 * I've removed the sentence.--Brianann MacAmhlaidh (talk) 01:56, 20 September 2016 (UTC)


 * "Gallovidian" is a term that will not be familiar to many readers.
 * I've wiki-linked the word to a disambig page (Gallovidian) where it states "A person from Galloway" with a reference from OED Online.--Brianann MacAmhlaidh (talk) 01:56, 20 September 2016 (UTC)


 * "(died ×1296) What does the cross mean? That's not notation I'm familiar with, which suggests that it won't be familiar to many readers
 * Multiplication signs are used by historians in date ranges. This one means "no later than 1296". Here's a quotation from New Hart's Rules: The Oxford Style Guide viewable on Google Books: I've wiki-linked "×" which redirects to "Multiplication sign" where this is covered. I've piped "c." in John I Comyn's death-date to "circa", and the first instance of "fl." at the beginning of the article is already piped to "floruit".--Brianann MacAmhlaidh (talk) 01:56, 20 September 2016 (UTC)


 * "If the aforesaid hostages of 1266" First, no hostages were actually mentioned, and, second, you should avoid self-references. You could go for something like "The populations of the territories passed to Alexander III"
 * The hostages are referred to in the last sentence of the preceding paragraph ("Scottish exchequer records also reveal that the Scottish Crown held several Manx hostages as a means to insure order on the island"). I didn't realise "aforesaid" was poor form on Wikipedia. I've just realised that I've overused the term in articles I've recently worked on, so I'll have to take care of those too. Anyway, I've removed the word and the year from the sentence, so now it's just "If the hostages were still held by the Scots a decade later...".--Brianann MacAmhlaidh (talk) 01:56, 20 September 2016 (UTC)


 * "the aforesaid Alan" Again, this is a self-reference. I personally like it (it reads well!) but there are good reasons for avoiding it on WP.
 * I've removed "aforesaid".--Brianann MacAmhlaidh (talk) 01:56, 20 September 2016 (UTC)


 * "lightly-armed and poorly trained rebels were soundly crushed by well-armed Scottish warriors" You should probably be consistent with your dash use- i.e., poorly-trained.
 * Got it.--Brianann MacAmhlaidh (talk) 01:56, 20 September 2016 (UTC)


 * "ten times fifty, three times ten and five and two did fall; O Manx race, beware lest future catastrophe you befall" Perhaps you could provide this in its original language (I'm guessing Latin?) A footnote may be preferable to inline.
 * Done.--Brianann MacAmhlaidh (talk) 01:56, 20 September 2016 (UTC)


 * Do we know the identity of Guðrøðr's wife?
 * I haven't come across anything else about her in secondary sources. As far as I know she's only attested by one sentence in one source describing their flight to Wales.--Brianann MacAmhlaidh (talk) 01:56, 20 September 2016 (UTC)


 * Perhaps the third paragraph of the "rise and fall" section could be labelled "aftermath" or something.
 * Done.--Brianann MacAmhlaidh (talk) 01:56, 20 September 2016 (UTC)


 * Could you explicitly state somewhere that the identity of Guðrøðr's mother is unknown?
 * The thing is that I don't think any of the secondary sources I've read actually state that his mother is unknown. They go no further than labelling him as "illegitimate".--Brianann MacAmhlaidh (talk) 01:56, 20 September 2016 (UTC)


 * Is Moore a "primary source"? Otherwise, your sourcing looks impeccable.
 * I used it as a primary source for the English translation of the "O Manx race" bit. Other translations I've come across for this passage are worse in my opinion. For example, one starts off: "".--Brianann MacAmhlaidh (talk) 01:56, 20 September 2016 (UTC)


 * We have Category:Illegitimate children of monarchs and its subcategories, which may be a useful addition. I also wonder whether Category:Pretenders or a subcategory would be appropriate.
 * I've add both categories.--Brianann MacAmhlaidh (talk) 01:56, 20 September 2016 (UTC)


 * Final point; I'm getting very, very few hits on Google Scholar and Google Books when I search for this person. Is there an alternative spelling or alternative name which I should be searching for?
 * I've added "Godred Magnusson" to the lead.--Brianann MacAmhlaidh (talk) 01:56, 20 September 2016 (UTC)

A very interesting and well-put-together article. It's a shame that we don't (yet) have an article on the wider rebellion; I think some might complain that this article is basically just an article about the rebellion, but I've no doubt that the subject is notable enough in his own right for an article, and this article looks great. I'm sure I'll be happy to promote after a few fixes have been made. Please double-check my small edits. Josh Milburn (talk) 16:16, 18 September 2016 (UTC)
 * Hi Josh, thanks for reviewing this. I think I've addressed everything.--Brianann MacAmhlaidh (talk) 01:56, 20 September 2016 (UTC)
 * Ok, I made a final few tweaks and I'm happy to promote now. A pleasure to read; it's great that you're working on this area, which I imagine (based on my own experience) is not well-known. I look forward to seeing what you produce in the future. Josh Milburn (talk) 18:55, 25 September 2016 (UTC)
 * Thanks Josh.--Brianann MacAmhlaidh (talk) 22:06, 28 September 2016 (UTC)