Talk:HEX.com diamond

The diamond's record status
User:JunkBondTrader89 I agree with you that it's helpful to explain that it's a black cut diamond within the opening sentence.

However your logic about its record is wrong. It is the world's largest cut diamond as the many articles have reported prior to its recent sale (please provide a counter example if you don't agree). Also the exact wording of the Guinness World Record is: 'The world's largest cut diamond is a unnamed Fancy Black'; the title seems to be erroneous (again if you disagree, please provide details of a bigger cut diamond). So it doesn't need, and mustn't have a qualifier as having one in actuality would be misleading; not the other way around as you are suggesting. Because it would imply that it's not the world's largest diamond.

So it is correct to say it's a black cut diamond, and also that it's the largest cut diamond on Earth. But the clauses can not be combined. nunmap (edit this page to talk) 23:57, 31 August 2022 (UTC)