Talk:Hamid Naderi Yeganeh

Comments on his work
I'm moving this section from the article to the talk page. It has value as background information, but is not encyclopedic and should not be in the article in its current form. User:力 (power~enwiki, π,  ν ) 17:06, 22 April 2021 (UTC)

"In 2015, CNN used the question 'Is this the next da Vinci?' for the title of a video about Naderi Yeganeh's work and RT en Español used the question 'New da Vinci?' at the beginning of the title of an article about him and Al Arabiya used this question for the article about Naderi Yeganeh: 'Is this Iranian student da Vinci's successor?'. And Iranian media such as IRNA and Isfahan Ziba titled him as 'The Iranian da Vinci' and 'Iran's da Vinci' in their articles about Hamid Naderi Yeganeh.  In 2015, Asia Society Philippines stated in a post on Facebook that 'Hamid Naderi Yeganeh reveals the beauty of Math through Art'.  In 2015, The National Museum of Mathematics stated in a post on Facebook that 'Hamid Naderi Yeganeh takes graphing art to the next level!' In 2016, Institute for Mathematics and its Applications commented on the Naderi Yeganeh's blog post showing how to draw human faces with mathematical equations: 'Another reason that math wins'. In 2016, COSMOS raised this question in the introduction to its interview with Hamid Naderi Yeganeh: 'Why couldn't high school mathematics be more like this?' in order to get its readers thinking about the potential of using Naderi Yeganeh's work in mathematics education. In 2016, Mathematics in Education and Industry stated in a tweet that: 'Hamid Naderi Yeganeh is a mathematical artist who's created plant images by trigonometric functions.' In 2016, Barbour Design Inc. stated on its own blog that 'These often delicately intricate works are quite remarkable, and more astounding is that Yeganeh writes computer programs based on mathematical equations to produce them.' In 2017, Mathematical Association of America commented about one of Naderi Yeganeh's animations in a tweet: 'Watch the beauty of trigonometric functions come alive'. In 2017, Fields Institute described Naderi Yeganeh's work as 'beautiful math' in a tweet. In 2017, Berkeley Lab commented on one of Naderi Yeganeh's blog posts: 'Create stunning symmetrical images armed with a few equations and a computer'."


 * I'd have thought that these citations could readily be used to support a "Reception" section or paragraph, with the text consisting of neutral, encyclopedic statements of the form "X stated that Yeganeh's work was Y". These directly demonstrate notability as well as indicating the breadth of interest in his output. Chiswick Chap (talk) 12:51, 28 August 2021 (UTC)


 * @Chiswick Chap, as I see (as a new Wiki user) all of the sentences in the paragraph are neutral. For example, the paragraph begins with


 * In 2015, CNN used the question "Is this the next da Vinci?" for the title of a video about Naderi Yeganeh's work ...


 * I think it is "X stated Y about Yeganeh". What is your opinion about this sentence? Is it neutral? Math CRXVC (talk) 18:28, 29 August 2021 (UTC)

@Chiswick Chap and @Math CRXVC, I propose the paragraph below as a replacement to the above paragraph. I removed material from Al Arabiya, RT en Español, IRNA and Isfahan Ziba and I changed a few verbs to make the paragraph more encyclopedic. Any comment? ReakMonars (talk) 15:32, 17 September 2021 (UTC)

"In 2015, CNN used the question 'Is this the next da Vinci?' for the title of a video about Naderi Yeganeh's work. In 2015, Asia Society Philippines stated on a Facebook post that 'Hamid Naderi Yeganeh reveals the beauty of Math through Art'. In 2015, The National Museum of Mathematics stated in a post on Facebook that 'Hamid Naderi Yeganeh takes graphing art to the next level!' In 2016, Institute for Mathematics and its Applications commented on the Naderi Yeganeh's blog post showing how to draw human faces with mathematical equations: 'Another reason that math wins'. In 2016, COSMOS raised this question in the introduction to its interview with Hamid Naderi Yeganeh: 'Why couldn't high school mathematics be more like this?' in order to get its readers thinking about the potential of using Naderi Yeganeh's work in mathematics education. In 2016, Mathematics in Education and Industry stated in a tweet that: 'Hamid Naderi Yeganeh is a mathematical artist who's created plant images by trigonometric functions.' In 2016, Barbour Design Inc. stated on its own blog that 'These often delicately intricate works are quite remarkable, and more astounding is that Yeganeh writes computer programs based on mathematical equations to produce them.' In 2017, Mathematical Association of America commented about one of Naderi Yeganeh's animations in a tweet: 'Watch the beauty of trigonometric functions come alive'. In 2017, Fields Institute referred to Naderi Yeganeh's work as 'beautiful math' in a tweet."


 * Support, I'm quite unclear why the paragraph should have been removed in the first place, as it is extremely reliably sourced, neutral, directly relevant, and serves to establish Yeganeh's notability. But your version is fine. Chiswick Chap (talk) 15:36, 17 September 2021 (UTC)


 * @Chiswick Chap and @Math CRXVC, I added the paragraph to the article under a section named "Reception". ReakMonars (talk) 15:55, 17 September 2021 (UTC)