Talk:Hammerspace

Contradictions
Okay, this topic is Corky-level retarded, but not any more so than any other "fandom"-related topic on Wikipedia. However, those responsible for posting the crap should, at least, fix the following.


 * Second paragraph: "...the term itself both originates in and is generally associated with Japanese entertainment."
 * Third paragraph (the very next sentence): "Hammerspace originated in western animation."

Let the asinine retard debate begin! Just don't squeal too loud, or else your parents will kick you out of their basement.


 * Actually, that's not a contradiction. The word "Hammerspace" itself does originate ("The term itself", the first statement goes) with anime, particularly fanfiction based on Ranma 1/2 and similar series'.


 * However, the 'act of whipping a mallet out of nowhere and twhomping somebody upside the head is an old gag from the classic Merrie Melodies/Looney Tunes and MGM cartoons and such.


 * Bu for wiki's sake, I'll see if I can clarify it more. [[User:SAMAS|SAMAS 14:31, 19 February 2007 (UTC)

Washuu's Hammerspace & Tenchi Muyo
I'd have to say that that is one that really deserves a listing here as it is an explicit reference and even called "Hammerspace" in the series. One of the few times that Hammerspace is actually called Hammerspace in the series itself. Washuu is first seen pulling items out of nowhere in such a fashion, and disappears regularly, later it is revealed that she actually has a complete secret laboratory & workplace in the Hammerspace.

-nnx

Lum and Hammerspace
I haven't seen every single episode of Urusei Yatsura, so I'm hesitant to change thing, but I've never seen Lum pull anything out of Hammerspace. She tends to rely on her own natural powers of electrocution to punish men she gets mad at. Shinobu has done so, maybe it should be changed to her?


 * I own the entire manga series, although the books are not with me at the moment. While not 100% sure that Lum has NEVER pulled any large weaponry out from nowhere, I don't think she makes a good example at all.


 * In fact, a hammer out of hammerspace is best associated with Ataru in this story. Shinobu uses mainly classroom desks as both her melee and missle weapon.  Although sometimes seen physically carrying his sword before he draws, Mendo stores his katana in this hammerspace just as often.  I seem to remember scenes in which Benten and Ran teleport in heavy firearms, too.


 * All in all, if a character does not usually fight bare-handed, s/he would frequently make use of this hammerspace through out the series. Unfortunately, Lum just falls into the other category. Pthow 06:20, 14 July 2006 (UTC)

Interesting. Hammerspace seems to be the same extra dimension where immortals in the Highlander universe keep their swords. RickK 20:50, 22 Nov 2003 (UTC)


 * Sighs* I don't know, it could use some wikification (?). --Merovingian 10:35, Jan 2, 2004 (UTC)

This should probably be combined with Hammertime into a Hammer space-time continuum article, as soon as references to the appropriate research articles are found; I believe Stephen Hawkman (who also has no article yet!) has written a whole book on it. I'll look into it this weekend. Oh, and to RickK: yours is a common misconception; the Highlander swords actually come from plot holes (objects so dense that common sense cannot escape them) which Hawkman also writes about. His theory that plot holes may emit obfuscation has met with great critical acclaim among physicists. --JRM 14:46, 2004 Sep 17 (UTC)


 * Did you mean Stephen Hawking? --Miles 19:21, Jan 16, 2005 (UTC)


 * Hammertime does not appear to be a dimension. -Litefantastic 00:57, 16 Feb 2005 (UTC)


 * I think that wooshing noise was a joke flying over your head. :) --Steven Fisher 09:42, 3 Apr 2005 (UTC)


 * The Hammer space-time continuum? Is that where he gets the parachute pants from? I believe Albert Einstein did some work on this and came up with E=MCHAMMER. smurray  inchester ( User ), ( Talk ) 17:31, 28 December 2005 (UTC)


 * I'm afraid you are sorely mistaken, sir! E clearly equals MCHawking


 * Whoever removed the Hammertime quote has some issues with humor. I put it back in. Cougar Draven 22:03, 20 March 2006 (UTC)
 * According to my talk page, it's SB, and according to his page, this article has bewinged a Pokémon. :¬) AKismet 20:35, 4 February 2007 (UTC)
 * That's not fancruft. That's a joke (and a bad one at that. But hey, I like bad jokes!). SAMAS 14:35, 19 February 2007 (UTC)

Merge with magic satchel?
I think this article should be merged with magic satchel and expanded to talk more about the general concept of cartoon characters producing things from or sending things to thin air. For example, Wile E. Coyote will frequently produce signs saying "Help!" or "Oh no!" from nowhere. Conversely, when Optimus Prime transforms, his trailer just sort of disappears into nowhere land. And then there's Mary Poppin's magic bagÉ Anyhow it's a broad topic, so it might be cool to expand the scope a little. --Carl 03:13, 17 May 2005 (UTC)
 * That's an interesting idea that I like. Hammerspace isn't a great term for it However, I think magic satchell should have more obvious cartoon/gaming sections. --Steven Fisher 06:43, 17 May 2005 (UTC)
 * No! The underlying concept is the same, but the connotations are different. -Litefantastic 16:29, 17 May 2005 (UTC)
 * I like the idea of combining it into one article but don't know if magic satchell is the right term to use. I don't have a better option, though....[cartoon space-time]?  Maybe not....NoahB 19:32, 17 May 2005 (UTC)
 * Leave unmerged. The Magic Satchel is more for carrying items and weapons in RPGs.  Hammerspace is in manga and generally for comedic effect.  I have to concur with whoever added the cleanup tag though --TexasDex 05:46, July 30, 2005 (UTC)

I think the main difference between the Magic Satchel and Hammerspace is that the Magic Satchel is an actual physical thing, such as The Luggage from Discworld, or D&D's Bag of Holding, and is special in itself and accessible to anybody, while Hammerspace is a distortion in space, traditionally entered by reaching behind you. The laws are similar but the method of use is different. This brings into debate who uses Hammerspace and who uses a Magic Satchel. --Some Girl called Harley.


 * No, the Magic Satchel is a bag containing Hammerspace, if you wish to be accurate about it. I'm quoting my friend Shimbozy on this one. Cougar Draven 22:03, 20 March 2006 (UTC)

Hmmm... Makes sense. (edits) Some Girl Called Harley.

Error in how to carry katana
As a practitioner of the Japanese sword, I must express that the carrying of the katana on the back was NOT the 'normal' way to do it. Most Japanese swordschools carried the katana on the left hip, with edge upwards to faciliate quick drawing of the sword (iaijutsu).

Carrying the sword on the back is simply not too practical, especially for a horseman.


 * I also noticed that error. Someone should remove the offending segment. I'll do it.

A Katana worn on the back was for transport purposes, like a slung rifle, and never for combat. Other swords perhaps, but mostly these too were slung for ease of carriage rather than combat-accessibility. Anybody with a sword collection (like me) who has tried the "back-slung quick draw" (like me) will tell you that you risk an ear or a jugular vein if you don't get it right (like me). Incidentally, note Blade's sword in the movie. it is physically impossible to draw a weapon of that length from a back-scabbard, given the length of his arm over the length of the blade. Same applies to many "Ninja swords". STEALTH RANGER 08:08, 9 July 2007 (UTC)

The Matrix
I don't really care one way or the other -- some other guy was the one who first added the Matrix comment to this article -- but it is interesting that the movie is so obvious about its Hammerspace-like qualities. Bugs Bunny just grabs anvils from behind his back, RPG characters just happen to all wear truck-sized satchels, but in the Matrix, we actually get to see the storage room, the martial arts center, etc. It's kind of like the difference between traditional magicians, who don't show you how the trick is done, and Penn & Teller. Mareino 19:02, 19 November 2005 (UTC)


 * If the Matrix counts as hammerspace, so does any cyberspace. Neo doesn't pull anything out of the Matrix; they're all imaginary toys in an imaginary world. Training is not part of any Hammerspace I've seen generally agreed to be a Hammerspace. --Prosfilaes 19:41, 19 November 2005 (UTC)

Maybe not the Matrix itself or the training program but the "loading program" which Neo and Trinity go into when they arm up before going to free Morpheus. Skiny-boy says to the operator "We're going to need guns. Lots of guns." At which point the walk-in closet of David Koresh comes sliding up on either side of them like a couple of high-speed trains. Cy4

Perhaps the closet IS Hammerspace. In the film the guns are computer programs, but it's like they're telling you "This is where your mallet/potion goes when you put it away," or "This is where your backpack leads." --Some Girl Called Harley.


 * No, no, no, no, NO! There are no Hammerspace references in the Matrix. At most, the construct takes place in Hammerspace, but that's stretching it. And I don't like stretching it. Once again quoting Shimbozy, Hammerspace is when you pull a quarter from behind a kid's ear. The construct is like walking into a closet filled with whatever you want it to be. Like a unlimited genie wish in the form of a closet. Cougar Draven 22:03, 20 March 2006 (UTC)

Hammerspace in non-animated movies
Don't forget the originator of Hammerspace in non-animated films: Harpo Marx could pull a hammer, horn, or cup of coffee out of his coat or even out of thin air.

Golden Age
It's also common in Golden and Silver age comic books.

Batman and Green Arrow were both notorious for pulling things out of nowhere, and in the 60's Batman show, he once pulled a live fish out from his belt.


 * Technically, and once again Shimbozy in here (he's apparently too lazy to log in and find this himself), those are small Magic Satchels. Cougar Draven 22:03, 20 March 2006 (UTC)

Highlander!
Does Hammerspace have any connection with Duncan MacLeod's ability to pull a sword out of his hip pocket?


 * After discussing with Shimbozy, I'm gonna have to say no to that. In terms of actual definition, Hammerspace is a dimensional rift, such as can be found in places like the Bermuda Triangle and Canada, and it is obstructed in some way, and the Magic Satchel is just a container of Hammerspace, and not Hammerspace itself. Since he is pulling it out of his hip pocket, he is not reaching into Hammerspace (i.e. behind his back), but into a Magic Satchel container of Hammerspace. Magic Satchels can only contain a limited amount of Hammerspace. Like the 99-Potion limit in Pokemon or Final Fantasy. Shimbozy and I do dispute this, so he will likely aruge his opinion within the next day or so. And by "or so", I mean whenever he feels like it. Cougar Draven 22:03, 20 March 2006 (UTC)

too much game descriptions
There is too much game description in "hammerspace in games". Many, many games can be considered using"hammerspace". Citing them individually will make the article too big, and dont add anything to it. I just left some that serves as genre examples (fps, adventures, etc...).SSPecteR 01:02, 21 March 2006

AGREED STEALTH RANGER 08:12, 9 July 2007 (UTC)


 * What he said, though a bit louder. --Kizor 18:01, 11 June 2006 (UTC)


 * I trimmed the list today. Someone else can reinstate really notable examples if they like, or trim further, but there's no sense in that section being longer than the rest of the article combined. -- nae'blis (talk) 03:45, 26 July 2006 (UTC)

Transformers
I contend that Optimus Prime's trailer deserves mention. -Etafly

As with Etafly, I agree with the comment regarding Optimus Prime's trailer, but find it to be the most extreme example of the Transformers using Hammerspace in the 1984-1987 cartoon (and its Japanese spinoffs). While Rodimus Prime's trailer (in toy form) should also qualify him for the Optimus example, he has only been shown transforming to vehicle mode in this way twice (the first being his first transformation in The Transformers: The Movie's closing scenes). On a minor level, any Transformer who carried weapons in robot mode, yet had no place on their persons to carry them in alternate modes (such as Jazz, an unarmed race car, transforming into a robot while whipping an unseen rifle from behind his back) had access to hammerspace (originally called sub-space by the Transformers fan community). This example is generally compared to each robot's action figure, and where -- if at all -- weapons were stored on it. Dreamwave Productions attempted to resolve the hidden weapon issue in their Generation 1 comic series by showing Optimus Prime ejecting an collapsable/expandable rifle from his back into waiting right hand. Among the few Transformers not to be shown (frequently) using this practice were the Decepticon planes (whose weapons merely transferred from their wings to their arms) and the Targetmasters (whose weapons were carried externally in both modes, when not transformed into exo-suit wearing humanoids). -Cybertronian

Congratulations!
I would just like to take a moment of my time to thank the Wikipedia contributors for putting together the funniest article I've read in a long time. Keep up the good work! Ppk01 17:55, 13 April 2006 (UTC)
 * I do think that the comparison to peanut butter jelly time stretches the joke at the end too far, but invoking the "postulates of the theory of relativity" in comparing Hammerspace to Hammertime is brilliant. --Kizor 20:13, 16 April 2006 (UTC)

Peanut butter jelly time is a little silly, but among with Hammerspace/Hammertime it goes pretty well with the feel of this article. Too many people think that adding ANY humour to Wikipedia will turn it into Uncyclopedia. Atzel 16:43, 29 April 2006 (UTC)

On the "Hammertime" thing. Allow me to thank you for leaving that in. It meshes with the feel of the subject and the entry and makes it worth reading. 24.48.159.136 02:04, 29 September 2006 (UTC)

Stargate
In the movie, and expounded upon in the TV shows, those who enter the Stargate first pass into a kind of higher dimension before being compressed and sent through the wormhole. Could this be considered a form of Hammerspace as well? --Savantster 19:23, 6 August 2006 (UTC)


 * No, I think you've misunderstood the subject of the article. It relates to how fictional characters can procure either oversized or unlikely objects out of nothing. What is discribed in Stargate sounds more like a "pocket dimension"... which there isn't an article for, currently. Instead it re-routes to Plane_%28Dungeons_%26_Dragons%29. Atzel 19:54, 21 September 2006 (UTC)


 * it's a totally differnt thing:a wormhole:a tunnel of indefinite energy that connects different place or time period.and it's used in a lot of fantasy and science fiction with the generical name of time-space portal

Why hasn't this been deleted?
This article is completely asinine. Why hasn't it been deleted because of the no original research policy? Or the fact that it's competely unencyclopedic? Do the authors honestly think animation writers think of this as some sort of "theory"? It's like having a detailed medical article on the exaggerately large eyes and tiny noses of anime characters. Do you want to know what "hammerspace" is? Durr, it's COMEDY. End of article. If someone would like to justify why this should exist as an article, please do so. Otherwise I'll propose it for deletion. The most "hammerspace" deserves is perhaps a small mention on the cartoon physics page, at best. --Marcg106 01:47, 18 September 2006 (UTC)
 * Please see the above section. If none of those references meet your criteria, then you'd probably be okay moving foreward. -Litefantastic 01:58, 18 September 2006 (UTC)

maybe this article's not within WP guidelines after all...
From Wikipedia:Avoid neologisms

"Neologisms that are in wide use — but for which there are no treatments in secondary sources — are not yet ready for use and coverage in Wikipedia. They may be in time, but not yet. The term does not need to be in Wikipedia in order to be a "true" term, and when secondary sources become available it will be appropriate to create an article on the topic or use the term within other articles.

An editor's personal observations and research (e.g. finding blogs and books that use the term) are insufficient to support use of (or articles on) neologisms because this is analysis and synthesis of primary source material (which is explicitly prohibited by the original research policy). To paraphrase Wikipedia:No original research: If you have research to support the inclusion of a term in the corpus of knowledge that is Wikipedia, the best approach is to arrange to have your results published in a peer-reviewed journal or reputable news outlet and then document your work in an appropriately non-partisan manner."

Blueaster 04:06, 8 October 2006 (UTC)

The article is notable. I have seen articles kept on 500 GHits. --DavidHOzAu 01:44, 9 October 2006 (UTC)
 * ggl:hammerspace 23200 GHits
 * ggl:hammerspace -wikipedia 16200 GHits

that is not my point. wikipedia should only contain information already published somewhere else. the fact that this article is the top google result says something about this term's actual documentation versus the significance that WP is artificially giving it.

Wikipedia shouldn't be popularizing neologisms or contain editor's observations and conclusions, it should give verifiable information from reliable sources that are then cited. Blueaster 02:27, 9 October 2006 (UTC)


 * So the problem is actually that the article doesn't seem to have many references? Then look it up and fix it!
 * My personal opinion is that this is not a neologism because I am quite sure that "Hammerspace" was in use before Wikipedia got off the ground. I think I first heard of it in an anime, (I've forgotten the name, there were so many I watched at the time,) which would have been about five or so years ago when I last watched anime of any sort.  The article is younger than that; I do not see any propagation of a neologism taking place. --DavidHOzAu 13:07, 13 October 2006 (UTC)

Age doesn't matter. A neologism is a word that's coined by a person. It doesn't matter if Hammerspace was invented last year or 10 years ago. What matters is that we should only rely on verifiable information from secondary sources, which would be very hard to do if all that exists of Hammerspace is primary sources on the word. Neologisms can spread very rapidly and become accepted much earlier than secondary sources can document them. Blueaster 23:16, 13 October 2006 (UTC)


 * I believe that there are some references in a section above. The talk pages of Attribution also has some interesting comments about what constitutes a reliable source.
 * Sorry I hadn't gotten around to reply to you earlier, it's been a busy month. --DavidHOzAu 06:13, 26 October 2006 (UTC)

Ok, this should work. AnimeInfo's Anime Physics 101 Lesson 4. I've got a soft spot for this article. Cougar Draven 02:03, 12 November 2006 (UTC)

Various Shtuffs
I've added Original Research templates to the Hammerspace in Games section and the Similar Concepts section.

I've done this because these sections are obviously based off of editors' opinions, observations, and analyses.

Unless you can come up with a source, we definately have to get rid of those sections.

Besides, "Hammerspace" is purely an anime fandom term, and so we have to keep it strictly in the context of anime fandom. The "see also" is good enough for similar concepts.

And based off of my above argument, I suggest we get rid of "The Toon role-playing game refers to this space as the back pocket."

sorry for being such an a$$, but I really want this article to be really good. I'm thinking of even adding a picture to this, or maybe asking the creator of 8 Bit Theatre to allow a pic of WM smashing BM on this article. Blueaster 02:40, 9 October 2006 (UTC)

Eega Beeva's pants
When I first read this article, I was reminded of Eega Beeva's pants. However, I'm not adding it to keep the article less cluttered. --ZeroOne ( talk | @ ) 12:27, 21 October 2006 (UTC)
 * And I'm grateful for that. --Kizor 13:35, 27 October 2006 (UTC)

seriously..
"Hammerspace should not be confused with Hammertime." o_O i somehow dont think this belongs.. perhaps in WP:BAD but not here.. lol.. Plough | talk to me 23:52, 29 October 2006 (UTC)

i agree. unless someone can logically argue for its inclusion, i say we delete this and KEEP IT OUT FOR GOOD (meaning, stop reverting it back, you losers) Blueaster 03:21, 10 November 2006 (UTC)


 * Honestly, I disagree. I think that it's part of the core that makes the article worth reading. And it makes sense, when you actually think about it. Cougar Draven 02:06, 12 November 2006 (UTC)

Pardon me but, what exactly IS "hammertime"? I've checked some links on wiki but I still don't see what "hammertime" has to do with "hammerspace"... Unless, of course, you refer to the instances where hammerspace is used to produce a mallet as "hammertimes", but I consider that to be a little farfetched.
 * There is no relationship between the two, which is why it shouldn't really be mentioned (other than a phonetic similarity, but I think they're too dissimilar to include the header). VirogIt's notmy fault! 03:42, 16 November 2006 (UTC)

I think the bit of humor and the comparison isn't inappropriate as time and space are usually related =) Kail Ceannai 00:38, 21 November 2006 (UTC)


 * I recently made some research on the "Cartoon physics" page and I actually found some interesting statements there that would make the exsistance of a "hammertime & space continiuum" highly plausible. According to the article, 2 requirements must be met before a toon can break the laws of physics... 1: It has to be funnier than if it didn't break the laws of physics (hammerspace matches this category). 2: Precise timing (if a toon relied on hammerspace to solve all of his/her problems, it would with time get predictable and booring, canceling the effect of the first requirement). With these two requirements in mind, it seems like a toon has to consider timing about as much as action, in this case, hammerspace, which would create a sort of "hammertime", IE. certain times when hammerspace is even aviable for the toon in question, highly limiting it's use of hammerspace to make the times when the toon refrains to hammerspace to be as enjoyable and comical as possible... The above is just a heap of speculations and theories, brought to you by: 5 marshmallows and a hot cup of chocolate.


 * OK, I can kind of see where you're going, but shouldn't there be a "hammertime" article created for this concept before including it in this article, rather than linking to MC Hammer's "Can't Touch This"? As it is now, it reads like an entry on Encyclopedia Dramatica. While that's amusing, is it really appropriate on Wikipedia? Demaar 07:15, 30 April 2007 (UTC)

Note to all contributors:
Due to Hammerspace's fan-envisioned and simple natures, many, many MANY "similar" occurances of an inexhaustable number of works can be compared to HS ad nauseum. And so I think we should secure this article by setting boundaries on what can be mentioned, maybe just Anime and videogames, and Warner Bros cartoons (Anime and videogames both have heavy history and origins in Japan, and Hammerspace seems to have been inspired by Warner Bros cartoons) Blueaster 03:52, 29 December 2006 (UTC)

The Mask
The Mask also features a lot of hammerspace utility. Can any editor cover that in detail. — Ambuj Saxena (☎) 16:55, 20 February 2007 (UTC)

TO COMMENT ON THAT: This is true, The Mask does use a lot of hammerspace, although reason can be clarified.when the Mask of Loki is being worn, it magnifies aspects of the person's inner psyche; In the Dark Horse comic, a lot of this is centered on the little guy getting (an often brutal) revenge on the big guy. The movie version establishes early on that Stanley has a consuming obsession with cartoons, many of the Max Fleischer school. It is this aspect which is magnified When Stanley becomes the Mask. We could therefore argue that Hammerspace becomes involved because it exist in Stanley's cartoons, not because he is wearing the mask; There is no indicator of what would happen if a non-cartoon fan wearing the mask tried to access Hammerspace. Perhaps it would not occur to them to do so? STEALTH RANGER 08:25, 9 July 2007 (UTC)

Vandalism
A user with the IP number of 209.188.169.2 has been vandalising the page by removing all refrences to anime. He has been warned and is not being civil about this. He is doing out his own persona dislike of anime and not baseing it on any facts. He has presented to evidence for his case and is really distrupting the flow of the page. His edits cause the page to contradict itself and are malicious in intend. I feel this usuer should be banned and this page should be protected from unregistered users. If anyone can help me out with this, let me know. thanks in advance (Animedude 04:43, 27 February 2007 (UTC))


 * He just got his final warning on his user talk page so the very next time I see him do something like this I'll block him (unless some other admin beats me to it). Unfortunately his IP address is a shared school one, so I won't block it for long stretches. If he remains persistently focused on this article it may be better to semi-protect it for a while instead. Bryan Derksen 06:36, 27 February 2007 (UTC)

wow, you guys are such a bunch of tools.

it's personal, not persona


 * I've given this IP address a 48 hour block. If it resumes this nonsense afterward I'll go longer, and if that fails I'll go to semiprotection of this article. Anon, I recommend a more concilliatory approach in the future. You can't force through changes to articles through sheer stubborness, you have to convince people that you're right using valid reasoning rather than childish insults. Bryan Derksen 01:17, 28 February 2007 (UTC)

unneccisary crap
saying that thing about naruto is completely not needed, as well as the fact that the terms itself is fan made naming an action that happens in anime.

i seriously doubt that [insult deleted] wapanese made up hammerspace after the act started some 70 years before in american cartoons

you also have no proof that the term is accosiated with anime all the time either, and the fact that many more people know about mickey mouse and bugs bunny than ranmafag or whatever completely proves that wrong there. —The preceding unsigned comment was added by ANeoseeker (talk • contribs) 20:29, 1 March 2007 (UTC).


 * Well, at least you've signed up for an account now, that's a small bit of progress. But you still need to stop spewing insults if you want anyone to take you remotely seriously. More importantly, perhaps, you should also provide some sort of evidence or reference supporting your assertion that the term "hammerspace" predates anime and manga fandom's usage of it. The article already indicates that Warner Brothers cartoons had the magical "items out of nowhere" thing, so it's not even the case that the article is claiming that the japanese invented it - it's apparently just the terminology that you're objecting to, right? Bryan Derksen 00:39, 2 March 2007 (UTC)


 * And now you seem to be back to anonymous revert warring. I've blocked your IP for a week this time, and the next time you try it I'm going to semi-protect the article. This is getting silly. Bryan Derksen 07:28, 3 March 2007 (UTC)


 * Semi-protected for three weeks. Bryan Derksen 17:54, 3 March 2007 (UTC)


 * Insults aside, I agree Naruto shouldn't be there. Magicallydajesus 04:42, 16 July 2007 (UTC)

Too Many Examples

 * 1) Hammerspace in games and #Similar concepts need to be pared down. Really, not that many examples are needed. I'd do it, but I feel inadequate to determine which examples are more important, or notable. Perhaps someone more familiar with comics in general can do this? Stale Fries taste better 21:11, 13 March 2007 (UTC)
 * This happens from time to time. The article is inherently susceptible to example creep, and the best way we've found to deal with it has been to trim it down to representative instances occasionally. (Alas, I am currently imposed in several different ways, so I recommend calling on Blueaster or trying it yourself.) --Kizor 22:10, 13 March 2007 (UTC)


 * I've removed the Futurama Bender reference from the list of examples. Bender's chest cavity was never characterized as holding impossible quantities of stuff. Rather, the running gag was that the contents of his chest were constantly changing. The one time he crammed an entire human in there was just typical cartoon exaggeration. --Clayhalliwell 14:27, 21 March 2007 (UTC)


 * I agree. See 'concerns' section below. Magicallydajesus 07:48, 3 August 2007 (UTC)

Transformers
I really think that Optimus Prime's Trailer is a classic example of "Hammer Space".

Also, isn't Mass shifting in general a related concept? Instead of stuffing a hammer, stuffing every 19 out of 20 atoms in a personal dimension, etc.

Discworld
I noticed that there was an inclusion of the Library, but not the Luggage which was designed as a character as a personification of 'hammerspace' Gcrossan 21:48, 16 April 2007 (UTC)

The Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy
In Infocom's text adventure game The Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy (computer game), I remember there being an item called something like, "the thing your aunt gave you that you don't know what it is." It turns out that while the "thing" looks small on the outside, opening it reveals a cavernous space within. Enough space to carry many more items than the player could carry on his own without the "thing".

I'm not sure this qualifies as hammerspace, though. The "thing" never produced anything on its own. The only items that came out of the "thing" were those that the player had placed in it previously.

--Lance E Sloan 03:12, 26 April 2007 (UTC)


 * The Thing did originally contain one of the four fluffs in the game, if I remember correctly, but aside from that it never produced anything. It's more along the lines of the Magic Satchel, in that it can contain a (nearly) unlimited amount of inventory, and that it will reappear in your inventory later if dropped. --StarChaser Tyger 06:54, 15 May 2007 (UTC)

Similar concepts / Known uses
I suggest you to divide "Similar concepts" into two sections: Smiliar concepts and Known uses (or Known users), separing "classic hammerspace" users like Akane Tendo, Misty or Kaori Makimura where the object comes from nowere without any explanation from "particular cases" like Naruto, Mary Poppins or Ultra Violet where they have special objects or pesudo-physical laws capable to contain big items. This division can be refined, I suggest you to talk about it here for a while and then apply a separation. Bye! --151.38.18.125 17:18, 17 May 2007 (UTC)
 * Otherwise, you could simply rename "Similar concepts" to "Known users and similar concepts" and keep everything in a single section. Bye! --151.38.18.125 17:21, 17 May 2007 (UTC)

Hows about adding a few people?
Secret Squirrel is a big one. One of his main gags is to pull out oversized and convient enemy stopping weapons from his trench coat. Including a semi truck sized lock, in the "Egg" episode.

And perhaps add the fact that some anthropomorphs that are unclothed yet have imaginary pockets of skin that they take and put stuff in?


 * I did it for you, but I did a rushed job. Get some INITIATIVE! The article is also becoming dangerously overcrowded. Magicallydajesus 04:38, 16 July 2007 (UTC)

magic-technology vs hammerplace
fictional magician or magic-user or particular high-tech device that create thing out of thin air or by a small capsule are considered like hammerplace or not?maybe we have to add the section of similar concept.

Monkey Island reference
Wasn't there a reference to the "Hammerspace" idea in MI 1 or 2? IIRC at one point Guybrush puts a very huge dog into his "pocket", making some comment along the lines of "Now this really _is_ a bit over-the-top"... Does have anybody have the exact wording? 82.83.253.111 18:57, 16 June 2007 (UTC)

Ranma ½
The article refers to one of the characters in this producing hammers from nowhere. However I can find no reference to this in any article for the manga/anime itself or the particular character. "It is believed by some" is classic weaselling, and the slight smell of original research doesn't help. HTH HAND —Phil | Talk 09:05, 9 July 2007 (UTC)

Karin/Chibi Vampire section
I added a section about Karin/Chibi Vampire. I just watched lot of the episodes and I couldn't help noticing the hammerspace. So I took action. I didn't just sit around and whine about how somebody else should take action. INITIATIVE! Come get a helping! Magicallydajesus 04:21, 16 July 2007 (UTC)

HAMMERSPACE IN VIDEO GAMES- A THOUGHT
Given the nature of video gaming, and the equipment carried in one form or another by the characters; outside of titles like FIFA 2006 and other sport related games, can anyone think of a game that doesn't use hammerspace ? Discuss.

STEALTH RANGER 07:51, 17 July 2007 (UTC)


 * Did you read this article? Because it specifically points out that modern shooting games (Halo, Mercenaries, Red Steel, etc.) don't use hammerspace, only letting you carry two weapons at a time, for realism purposes. Magicallydajesus 19:38, 17 July 2007 (UTC)

Spot on old boy ! You're right, of course, by the time I'd plowed through the rest, I'd forgotten the point. My Apologies.

STEALTH RANGER 15:51, 26 July 2007 (UTC)

Concerns
I think this article s getting, or will soon be, overcrowded. People are adding whatever they feel like to the 'examples' section, and it has got to stop. There are so many instances of hammerspace in popular culture we can't possibly list, or try to list, all of them in this article. What we need to do is pare down the section so that it only contains the most clear and illustrative examples of hammerspace. I suggest we start by removing the Eyeshield 21 section, since it says right in there that the devil's handbook is responsible for it, and remove one of the Resident Evil, as there is no need for two of them.

Sincerely, Magicallydajesus 07:45, 3 August 2007 (UTC)

In what circumstances might carrying 44467.2 metric tonnes of gold lead to a loss of hunger?
Somewhat confused by the examples listed in relation to Minecraft. — Preceding unsigned comment added by 96.236.138.108 (talk) 16:29, 1 March 2015 (UTC)


 * That was pure original research, probably calculated from assuming each block is 1 cubic meter or something similar. I reworded it; it's enough to say "thousands of tonnes" rather than an exact number with decimal precision. And hunger has nothing to do with how much you carry. 134.204.220.36 (talk) 19:34, 11 July 2018 (UTC)

Remove the lists
So this thing's quickly turning into a TvTropes article - and not a good one, at that. If no one objects, I propose removing the lists as a whole and simply leave two or three notable examples - such as The Mask, Groucho Marx, and Mary Poppins. The rest need to go because hundreds of examples use hammerspace. — Preceding unsigned comment added by Axslayer33 (talk • contribs) 22:59, 23 August 2019 (UTC)

original research tag
Other editors have expressed similar concerns above, in different ways, but there's a good many dubious statements in this article. It was years before this article had any references at all. Of the three currently cited sources, the most reliable and on-point is a four-panel cartoon. The origin of the word itself is uncertain and unreferenced. The first two occurrences I see in newspapers.com happen in 2008, and one of them explicitly references this very article, so that's no help. Running an Ngram on Google Books comes up with literally nothing; pulling at the thread of the "the Ranma ½ fanfiction community" leads back to the earliest mention I can find, the title of a story supposedly dated Halloween 1996, although the story itself is no longer reachable. Retroactively assigning a 1990s anime term to examples found decades before (Looney Tunes, and Harpo Marx, whose bits would have originated in vaudeville), and to examples that don't involve any hammers, and to do all that without sources, that's original research. --Lockley (talk) 01:44, 15 July 2020 (UTC)

Hammerspace in The Kane Chronicles
A lot of people have been saying there’s too many examples, and that may be true, but upon reading this article I was instantly reminded of the imaginary “locker” in the Duat in the Kane Chronicles books. Main character Carter Kane uses his “locker” to carry and instantly retrieve his sword. He also traps a monster in there at one point. 72.188.17.58 (talk) 17:33, 22 December 2021 (UTC)