Talk:Hanu, Ladakh

Hanu is a one of the prime village of Aryan valley
Dear kautilya3, Why do you always deleted my edit on these wikepedia page whenever I add hanu as a part of Aryan valley region. Please add Aryan valley in Hanu village. Even the Mp of ladakh has address the parliament of bringing Aryan valley in a single adminstrative subdivision. Historically ,the Minaro didn't live under the rule of Ladakhi kingdom as they have a Different Culture and langauge as compared to other Culture of ladakh, they had a different kingdom  which extends from Hanu to darchik , The present name of these region is Aryan valley , before a  decade it used to know by the name of dha hanu region, and ladakhi people used to called it Brokyul in ancient time. Aryan valley was never a part of Ladakhi kingdom. You would find the reference in ladakhi history book. Aryan valley was always a different region and later it was added into Ladakh after the dogra ruled Ladakh. Aryan valley leader like throsali had sacrifice his life to protect from ladakhi kingdom ( you would find  reference in book). There is a festival still celebrate in hanu as " Throsali" festival in rememberence of him. He had died rather coming under Tibetic people of  ladakh that is Ladakhis,purigpa and Balti. There has been always a rivalry between Aryan valley people and the ladakhi kingdom since thousand of years. We are trying to reclaiming our lost history  and lost  adminstrative region  which remained  as a sperate region for thousand of years. Please don't be harsh on us, let us re write our lost history and culture, we are hardly 3000 in number and our( Brokpa langauge  and culture is coming to an end . We want to get it recognize and  save our  endangered langauge and culture for our younger generation Minaro123 (talk) 08:51, 21 December 2022 (UTC)


 * The "Aryan Valley" is a tourist brand. It is not a geographical entity. You should never use that term as if it is a real thing that exists.
 * As you know well, Hanu is not in the same valley as the other places! -- Kautilya3 (talk) 09:35, 21 December 2022 (UTC)

Aryan valley is a name of a Region ,it is not a river valley , It may not fit in the description of river valley. Aryan valley is a Region which had a different kingdom as compared to other part of it'sorrounding that is Ladakh and baltistan and these area has a people of Brokpa with different cultures and langauge. These region is is recognize by ladakh official and if you see the MP ladakh statement ,he mentioned Aryan valley  to make it as a adminstrative subdivision in loksabha parliament It was separate region from Ladakh from thousand of years. The Aryan valley is popularly known as 'Brogyul' in the ancient time , As you known name of a Region keep change , So present name of these Region is 'Aryan valley '  recognize by an reliable Indian newspaper like Indian Express  and many more.

The official website of ladakh administration has used " Aryan valley region," in their government administrative website. Search " Aryan valley Region" below in the reference for prove. https://ladakh.nic.in/gmdc-zanskar-completes-3rd-day-of-biological-tour/

Mentioned 2: Mp ladakh mention Aryan valley region to get  a separate subdivision. The reference is here , Search " Aryan valley" below https://ladakh.nic.in/mp-ladakh-raises-important-issues-in-the-parliament/ Minaro123 (talk) 10:22, 21 December 2022 (UTC)


 * It looks like you have forgotten what a reliable source is. You need to brush it up again. An MP is not a reliable source for anything. e-- Kautilya3 (talk) 10:45, 21 December 2022 (UTC)

The administration of India decides the region of its territory , And the government administration of UT Ladakh  in his website of Leh.nic.in, as "Aryan valley region" , then we should listen the administration government. A Administration government has a power to declare a region, subdivision and a State. We should listen their sources as reliable source
 * Does WP:RS say that governments are reliable sources? -- Kautilya3 (talk) 16:04, 21 December 2022 (UTC)
 * We call Allahabad by its real name even though its government calls it "Prayagraj". -- Kautilya3 (talk) 16:06, 21 December 2022 (UTC)

Factoids
TrangaBellam (talk) 14:29, 23 January 2023 (UTC)
 * Gompa
 * Copper Sulfate mine