Talk:Harmoniemusik

"Evolve into military band..."
From intro: "would later evolve into the military band." Perhaps they influenced contemporaneous and later military bands, but I'm reading Hansen's The American Wind Band, and it clearly describes military bands in the New World predating this article's timeline for harmoniemusic in the Old World. Of course, military bands came from the Old World especially 1600s and were formed in the New World throughout that century and into the next (many sources confirm this from Camus to Hansen). So, I don't think the evolutionary timeline is accurate here. Military bands predate or at least coincide with harmoniemusik (as this article presents its timeline). — Preceding unsigned comment added by 198.108.80.177 (talk) 12:34, 6 October 2011 (UTC)

"evolve into the military band"?
From intro: "would later evolve into the military band." Perhaps they influenced contemporaneous and later military bands, but I'm reading Hansen's The American Wind Band, and it clearly describes military bands in the New World predating this article's timeline for harmoniemusic in the Old World. Of course, military bands came from the Old World especially 1600s and were formed in the New World throughout that century and into the next (many sources confirm this from Camus to Hansen). So, I don't think the evolutionary timeline is accurate here. Military bands predate or at least coincide with harmoniemusik (as this article presents its timeline). — Preceding unsigned comment added by 198.108.80.177 (talk) 12:36, 6 October 2011 (UTC)