Talk:Hazi Mohammad Mohsin Government High School

Proposal for two Mohsin School


As the Rajshahi and Chittagong's Mohsin schools have the same name but spelled little differently. So my proposal for this two school's article name and redirects is:-
 * Chittagong's Mohsin School:-
 * 1) Article Name- Hazi Mohammad Mohsin Government High School
 * 2) Redirects- Hazi Mohammad Mohsin Government High School, Chittagong, Haji Muhammad Mohsin Government High School, Chittagong

Farhansnigdho (talk) 17:37, 10 January 2024 (UTC)
 * Rajshahi's Mohsin School:-
 * 1) Article Name- Haji Muhammad Mohsin Government High School, Rajshahi
 * 2) Redirects- Haji Muhammad Mohsin Government High School, Hazi Mohammad Mohsin Government High School, Rajshahi


 * @Farhansnigdho
 * Haji Muhammad Mohsin Government High School should redirect to Hazi Mohammad Mohsin Government High School. The page was moved from Haji Muhammad Mohsin Government High School. Please see the edit history. GoddessFG (talk) 02:58, 11 January 2024 (UTC)
 * @GoddessFG For your kind information "Haji Muhammad Mohsin Government High School" is the official name or spelling of Rajshahi's Mohsin School See. It can't be used instead of Rajshahi's one. You should read the wiki policy and guidelines properly. But if you prefer you can use Haji Muhammad Mohsin Government High School, Chittagong for Chittagong's Mohsin High School.
 * Thank You -- Farhansnigdho (talk) 06:26, 11 January 2024 (UTC)
 * @Farhansnigdho The website you have mentioned here is not even the official one. I do not know which policy in Wikipedia supports to change the redirect in a redirect page which was created after moving a page. The Rajshahi's school was renamed in 2019. But the Chittagong's school used the name "Haji Muhammad Mohsin Government High School" earlier. The GSA system still uses the old one. See here FYI the Wikipedia article is also created in this title before the Rajshahi's one. How can you change the redirect where the page redirects to the moved page? Please see the edit history. Thank you. GoddessFG (talk) 04:00, 12 January 2024 (UTC)
 * @GoddessFG Firstly, official website is the most reliable and authentic source for any kind of organization or institution.
 * Secondly, There are many other sources as same type as the GSA system you have shown, which use that name for Rajshahi's School. So, those are not reliable.
 * Thirdly, Where did you see that the redirect target of a moved page cannot be changed???
 * Lastly, "Haji Muhammad Mohsin Government High School" has been using in Wikimedia Commons and Wikidata for Rajshahi's School long before the Chittagong's article was published on Wikipedia. -- Farhansnigdho (talk) 12:26, 12 January 2024 (UTC)
 * @GoddessFG Please read my proposal for article name and redirects carefully. I Hope that will fix the problem of two schools. -- Farhansnigdho (talk) 12:35, 12 January 2024 (UTC)
 * @Farhansnigdho First of all, why did you create a new redirect to Rajshahi's school with Chittagong's school's name spelling in it? I have not yet agreed to this proposal. Chittagong's school uses "Hazi Mohammad" instead of "Haji Muhammad" because Mohsin College started using it. Does Rajshahi's school have something like that? GoddessFG (talk) 16:54, 12 January 2024 (UTC)
 * @GoddessFG At first, Read Redirect's Puppose of redirects section properly. There clearly mentioned about alternative spelling and misspellings. And I have created the redirect page by mentioning Rajshahi at the end. So no one have any problem with it. Lastly, Wikipedia isn't anyone's private property. So, It doesn't matter who agreed to something or not -- Farhansnigdho (talk) 17:31, 12 January 2024 (UTC)