Talk:Heinrich Menu von Minutoli

Not Swiss
Minutoli was not Swiss. He is from age 14 a national of the Kingdom of Prussia. That is where we would categorize him primarily. For now I think the generals and scholars cats are the only Kingdom of Prussia categories we have to put him in. He was born in the Rwpublic of Geneva and is in that Category. We have evidence that by age 10 he had moved to I believe the Kargraviate of Baden in the Holy Roman Empire. That is a short placement. It looks like he may have been resident in the Holy Roman Empire for about 4 years. Although maybe longer. I do not think we have enough to need a Category for that. Especially since we really do not know when he left the Republuc of Geneva. He might technically be an immigrant to the Holy Roman Emoire, after all the Kingdom of Prussia was in much of its area part of the Holy Roman Rmpire, there is also the Province of Prussia that was beyond the limits of the Empire, but Silesia, Brandenburg, Westphalia, the Rhine Province and a few other areas were in the Empire. I would not object to Immigrants to the Holy Roman Empire but I doubt we need it considering the other categories we have. Immigrants to the Kingdom of Prussia might be better. At this time we do not have an Emigrants from the Republuc of Geneva Category.John Pack Lambert (talk) 14:35, 19 June 2024 (UTC)